A Better Way

360-Degree Feedback: Apparently I Have to Do My Manager's Fucking Job Too

There comes a magical time every year in corporate life when managers suddenly develop an intense interest in what their employees have been doing for the previous twelve months.

It's called the annual performance review.

An opportunity to reflect on achievements, discuss development, recognise contributions and establish objectives for the coming year.

At least, that's what the HR brochure says.

What actually happens is that you receive an email asking you to complete a self-assessment, document your achievements, provide evidence against seventeen competencies and nominate several colleagues to give feedback on your performance.

Hang on a fucking minute.

You're my manager.

What exactly have you been doing all year?

Because I've been working.

Quite a lot, actually.

I've delivered projects. Solved problems. Helped colleagues. Dealt with difficult situations. Taken responsibility when things have gone wrong and occasionally performed minor miracles to stop everything collapsing into a steaming pile of corporate bullshit.

And now you're telling me that none of this is sufficient evidence of my performance unless I find six other people willing to write something nice about me?

What the fuck are we paying you for?

Please nominate five colleagues to provide feedback

This is where the fun begins.

"To ensure a balanced and comprehensive assessment, please nominate colleagues who can provide 360-degree feedback on your performance."

Balanced.

Comprehensive.

Objective.

Three beautiful words describing a process in which I get to choose the people who assess me.

Think about that for a moment.

Imagine if the criminal justice system worked like this.

"Mr Smith, you've been accused of armed robbery. We'd like you to nominate five people who can provide an objective assessment of your character."

"Certainly, Your Honour. I'll nominate my mum, my wife, my best mate, my brother and Dave from the pub."

"Excellent. Very balanced."

"Would you also like to hear from the shopkeeper I threatened?"

"Only if you feel their feedback would support your development."

Fucking ridiculous.

Because let's be clear about how this actually works.

I'm not going to ask Bob for feedback.

Why?

Because I called Bob a cunt last Tuesday.

It was a particularly frustrating meeting, Bob was being a particularly frustrating cunt, and unfortunately the two events collided.

Now, Bob might have some genuinely valuable observations about my communication style, conflict management and ability to remain professional under pressure.

But am I going to nominate him?

Am I fuck.

I'm going to ask the people who like me.

The people I've helped.

The people who think I do a good job.

Preferably the people who owe me a favour.

And if one of them happens to think I'm the greatest employee since the invention of paid employment, even better.

Apparently, this is how we achieve objectivity.

Could you just mention a few things?

Now, here's the really beautiful part.

Not only do I select the people providing feedback, I can also tell them what I'd like them to comment on.

"Hi, Abdul. Would you mind providing some feedback for my annual review? It would be great if you could mention the project delivery, stakeholder management, technical leadership and the support I provided during the migration."

Translation:

Hello, Abdul.

Please write something nice about me.

I've helpfully provided the topics.

Try not to mention the incident with Bob.

Thanks.

And Abdul, being a decent bloke who I've worked with successfully, will probably write something genuinely positive.

Which is lovely.

But let's not pretend this is an independent investigation into my professional capabilities.

I've effectively commissioned my own fucking character reference.

And the company is treating it like an objective performance measurement.

It's the corporate equivalent of asking TripAdvisor to let restaurant owners choose which customers are allowed to leave reviews.

"Five stars. Excellent service. Outstanding leadership. Would collaborate again."

Brilliant.

Another successful year.

You scratch my back, I'll scratch yours

Of course, the genius of 360-degree feedback is that everyone gets to participate.

Today, I ask you to write something nice about me.

Tomorrow, you ask me to write something nice about you.

And because we're both reasonably intelligent adults who understand how the world works, neither of us is going to write:

"Kevin is an insufferable arse-licker who would sell his own grandmother for a five-minute conversation with the managing director."

Even if it's true.

Instead, we'll write something like:

"Kevin consistently demonstrates a proactive approach to stakeholder engagement and displays exceptional enthusiasm for organisational initiatives."

Which is corporate language for:

Kevin is an insufferable arse-licker who would sell his own grandmother for a five-minute conversation with the managing director.

And Kevin, naturally, will return the favour.

"An outstanding team player who consistently goes above and beyond."

Lovely.

We've both demonstrated excellence.

We've both supported each other's development.

And neither of us has said anything remotely useful.

But the HR system now contains two glowing testimonials, so presumably the process has been a tremendous success.

What about constructive feedback?

Now, the defenders of this system will point out that 360-degree feedback isn't supposed to be exclusively positive.

It's also designed to identify development opportunities.

Wonderful.

Let's see how that works.

"What could this individual do differently to improve their effectiveness?"

Well, Sandra could stop scheduling meetings that don't need to exist.

John could learn how to operate his fucking microphone.

Kevin could occasionally form an opinion that hasn't been personally approved by senior management.

And Bob could stop being a cunt.

But am I going to write any of that?

Of course not.

Because I have to work with these people tomorrow.

So instead, I write:

"Could benefit from continuing to develop their communication skills and exploring opportunities to further enhance cross-functional collaboration."

What does that mean?

Absolutely fucking nothing.

Could apply to anyone.

Could apply to the office photocopier.

But it sounds constructive, so everybody's happy.

And here's the irony: the more carefully people protect their working relationships, the less honest the feedback becomes.

We've created a system that claims to encourage openness while giving everyone a very good reason to avoid saying anything remotely uncomfortable.

Outstanding work, HR.

But surely your manager knows what you do?

This is the part that really gets me.

My manager is responsible for managing my performance.

That's literally the job.

It's not an obscure additional duty hidden in the small print.

It's in the fucking title.

Manager.

So why, after twelve months, am I expected to assemble a dossier proving that I've been doing my job?

Why do I have to remind you about the projects I've delivered?

Why do I have to list the problems I've solved?

Why do I have to explain the responsibilities I've taken on?

And why, having done all that, do I then need to find several witnesses who can confirm that I'm not making the whole thing up?

If I delivered a difficult project in March, led a successful implementation in June and spent September rescuing something that was heading spectacularly towards disaster, shouldn't you already know?

Shouldn't we have discussed it?

Shouldn't there be some record of the contribution I've made?

I'm not suggesting a manager should witness every email I send or every conversation I have. That would be ridiculous, particularly in large organisations where people work across multiple teams.

But there's a fairly significant difference between not seeing every detail of someone's work and having so little awareness of their contribution that they need to organise their own annual publicity campaign.

And if the employee is responsible for collecting the evidence, explaining its significance, obtaining supporting testimonials and documenting the results, what exactly is the manager contributing?

Apart from clicking Approve.

The self-assessment: Write your own fucking appraisal

Before we even get to the feedback, there's another delightful exercise.

The self-assessment.

"Please provide examples demonstrating how you have met or exceeded your objectives."

Right.

So now I'm writing my own performance review.

Excellent.

Would you like me to calculate my own pay rise while I'm at it?

Perhaps I could approve my own promotion.

I'll even book a meeting with myself to discuss my development opportunities.

"Paul, how do you think you've performed this year?"

"Exceptionally well, Paul. Thanks for asking."

"Any areas for improvement?"

"Possibly spending less time completing pointless corporate forms, Paul."

"Excellent insight. Very self-aware."

"Thank you, Paul."

"Promotion approved."

There.

I've just saved the company several hours of management time.

That's operational excellence, apparently.

And the really absurd thing is that self-assessments actively reward people who are good at writing self-assessments.

Someone who has quietly delivered exceptional work all year but struggles to describe their achievements may end up looking less impressive than someone who has achieved relatively little but can turn answering three emails into a strategic transformation initiative.

Kevin, naturally, has already completed his.

Thirty-seven pages.

With appendices.

He's described organising the Christmas Secret Santa as "leading a cross-functional employee engagement programme that enhanced organisational cohesion".

And somewhere, a manager is nodding appreciatively.

The annual scramble to remember what happened

Then there's the timing.

Why do we wait until the end of the year?

Why do we suddenly need to reconstruct twelve months of professional activity as though we're investigating an unsolved crime?

"What were your key achievements in February?"

February?

I can barely remember what I had for lunch on Tuesday.

Now you want me to recall the specific business impact of a technical decision I made nine months ago?

And of course, the things that are easiest to remember are the recent ones.

Something brilliant you did in January might disappear into the corporate fog.

But that presentation Kevin delivered last Thursday?

Fresh in everyone's memory.

Which means the annual review can end up measuring not just performance, but memory, visibility and the ability to write convincing bullshit.

Perhaps instead of making employees reconstruct the year retrospectively, managers could actually discuss performance throughout the year.

I appreciate this is a radical suggestion.

It would involve managing people.

Continuously.

Rather than discovering their existence every December.

The mysterious calibration meeting

And just when you think the process couldn't become any more ridiculous, your completed appraisal disappears into something called a calibration meeting.

This is where managers gather to discuss performance ratings and ensure consistency across the organisation.

Now, consistency is a perfectly reasonable objective.

But imagine the employee's perspective.

I've written my self-assessment.

I've documented my achievements.

I've gathered feedback from colleagues.

I've explained how I've met my objectives.

My manager has reviewed everything.

And now a room full of people, some of whom may barely know me, gets to discuss whether my performance is sufficiently excellent to qualify as officially excellent.

Apparently, excellence needs calibrating.

Perhaps I was outstanding, but unfortunately too many other people were also outstanding.

And we can't have that.

Someone has to be merely good.

Otherwise, the spreadsheet gets upset.

So after a year of actual work, several hours of administrative nonsense and an impressive collection of glowing testimonials, I might receive a rating that bears a surprisingly loose relationship to what I've actually achieved.

But don't worry.

The process has been calibrated.

Which makes everything better.

There is a sensible idea buried underneath all this bullshit

Now, before anyone from HR starts preparing a strongly worded email, I do understand the value of getting feedback from different people.

A manager doesn't see everything.

Someone working across several teams might contribute in ways their direct manager doesn't fully observe.

And colleagues can sometimes identify strengths and weaknesses that a manager would otherwise miss.

That's all perfectly reasonable.

In fact, genuinely honest feedback can be incredibly useful.

But that's not the same as asking employees to handpick their own reviewers, suggest what those reviewers should say and then presenting the resulting collection of compliments as an objective assessment.

Nor should gathering feedback become an excuse for managers to outsource responsibility for understanding the people they manage.

Use feedback to add perspective.

Don't use it as a substitute for paying attention.

And if you genuinely want to know how someone is performing, perhaps have regular conversations with them throughout the year rather than staging an elaborate corporate evidence-gathering exercise every December.

The final insult

After all this, you finally have your performance review meeting.

Your manager opens the document you've written.

They read the achievements you've listed.

They look at the feedback you've collected.

They consider the evidence you've provided.

Then they smile.

"Well, you've clearly had a really strong year."

Yes.

I fucking know.

I just spent three weeks proving it.

"Some really positive feedback from your colleagues."

Yes.

I know that too.

I asked them for it.

"Great examples of leadership and collaboration."

Again, I wrote those examples.

"Anything you'd like to add?"

Yes, actually.

I'd like to know why I've spent several hours doing the administrative work required for you to tell me something you should already know.

I'd like to know why my performance is apparently judged partly on my ability to persuade other people to write nice things about me.

And I'd particularly like to know why we're pretending that a collection of carefully selected compliments represents a balanced assessment of anything.

But of course, I don't say that.

I smile politely.

"Nothing from me, thanks."

"Brilliant. Well done on a great year."

"Thanks."

And then comes the inevitable final question.

"Any feedback for me as your manager?"

Oh, absolutely.

I've got some feedback.

Quite a lot, actually.

But seeing as you've just spent an hour reviewing my performance, and you'll probably have some influence over my next pay rise, I think I'll keep it constructive.

"Really appreciate your support throughout the year. Looking forward to continuing to work together."

There we go.

Five stars.

Outstanding leadership.

Would collaborate again.

And that, ladies and gentlemen, is the beauty of 360-degree feedback.

Everybody's fucking brilliant. Nobody's learned anything. And Bob's still a cunt.

#Corporate Fuckery