Best Practice: Because Thinking for Yourself Is Apparently Against Company Policy
There's a phrase in corporate life that makes me want to repeatedly bang my head against a fucking wall.
Best practice.
Two words.
Sounds sensible.
Sounds professional.
Sounds like something an intelligent person might say.
And yet, in the wrong hands, those two innocent little words become one of the most effective methods ever invented for eliminating creativity, originality and independent thought from an organisation.
Because corporate companies absolutely fucking love innovation.
They adore it.
They're passionate about it.
They want disruptive thinking.
Blue-sky thinking.
Creative solutions.
Transformational ideas.
They want employees to challenge convention, push boundaries, embrace change and think outside the box.
Provided, of course, that everybody follows best practice.
OH, DO FUCK OFF.
You can't spend Monday telling employees to challenge conventional thinking and Tuesday telling them they're not allowed to do something differently because it doesn't align with established best practice.
That's not innovation.
That's asking somebody to invent a new form of transport while insisting they use the fucking bus.
What Actually Is Best Practice?
Let's examine this magnificent concept.
Best practice generally refers to an established approach believed to produce good results.
Perfectly reasonable.
If somebody has already discovered an effective way of doing something, it makes sense to learn from their experience.
Nobody wants engineers reinventing electrical safety standards every Thursday.
Nobody wants surgeons experimenting with exciting new ways of washing their hands.
And nobody wants Quentin developing an innovative new spelling system for the English language.
Although that particular experiment appears to be well underway.
But here's the problem.
Somewhere inside the corporate machinery, the phrase best practice has stopped meaning:
"Here's a proven approach worth considering."
And started meaning:
"THIS IS HOW EVERYBODY ELSE DOES IT, SO STOP ASKING FUCKING QUESTIONS."
And that is an entirely different proposition.
Because best practice should be a starting point.
Not a prison sentence.
It should inform judgement.
Not replace it.
But unfortunately, judgement requires something that appears to be in dangerously short supply across corporate middle management.
A functioning fucking brain.
Welcome to the Innovation Workshop
Imagine the scene.
A large corporate organisation has decided it needs to become more innovative.
Apparently, innovation is now a strategic priority.
Fantastic.
So management organises an innovation workshop.
Naturally.
Because nothing encourages spontaneous creativity quite like a compulsory three-hour meeting scheduled six weeks in advance.
Twenty employees attend.
There's a facilitator.
There's a PowerPoint.
There's an interactive whiteboard.
And there's a photograph of a light bulb on the opening slide.
Because apparently, no corporate presentation about innovation can exist without a fucking light bulb.
Martin opens the session.
"We really want everyone to think outside the box today."
Wonderful.
"Don't be afraid to challenge conventional thinking."
Excellent.
"There are no bad ideas."
Really?
"Absolutely. We want blue-sky thinking."
Brilliant.
Raj raises his hand.
"I've been looking at our delivery process, and I think we could eliminate several unnecessary approval stages by changing how we handle lower-risk changes."
Silence.
Martin looks uncomfortable.
"Well, Raj, we need to be careful. We have to follow best practice."
And there it is.
THIRTEEN FUCKING MINUTES.
That's how long the innovation workshop lasted before somebody strangled the first genuinely useful idea.
Congratulations, Martin.
You've successfully demonstrated that innovation is welcome provided it doesn't involve changing anything.
Perhaps next week we could organise a swimming workshop where nobody's allowed to get fucking wet.
Blue-Sky Thinking, But Only Under an Approved Sky
Corporate innovation has become a fascinating exercise in contradiction.
Management wants employees to be creative.
But not too creative.
Original.
But not unconventional.
Bold.
But not risky.
Disruptive.
But not disruptive to anything that currently exists.
They want revolutionary ideas that can be implemented without changing processes, challenging authority, spending money or making anybody uncomfortable.
In other words, they want innovation without the inconvenience of actually innovating.
It's like asking somebody to paint a masterpiece but insisting they use the same colours, same brushes, same canvas and same composition as everybody else.
Then expressing disappointment when the result looks exactly the fucking same.
"Unfortunately, we're not seeing enough creative thinking."
NO SHIT, MARTIN.
YOU'VE JUST REJECTED EVERY IDEA THAT INVOLVES THINKING.
Perhaps the problem isn't the employees.
Perhaps the problem is the collection of middle management monkeys who believe creativity means rearranging the furniture in a room where nobody is allowed to open the fucking windows.
Imagine James Dyson Asking Permission
Let's consider James Dyson.
An inventor who spent years developing and refining his ideas for bagless vacuum cleaner technology.
Thousands of prototypes.
Repeated failures.
An obsession with solving a problem differently.
Now imagine Dyson working in a large corporate organisation.
He attends an innovation meeting.
"I've got an idea. What if we rethink the conventional vacuum cleaner and use cyclonic separation instead of relying on disposable bags?"
Martin looks concerned.
"Interesting, James. But is that aligned with industry best practice?"
"Well, the point is that I'm trying to develop something better."
"Yes, absolutely. We encourage innovation. But have you completed a best-practice assessment?"
"A what?"
"We'll need to establish whether the proposed approach aligns with existing market standards."
"But the existing approach is what I'm trying to improve."
"Understood. Perhaps we could arrange a workshop with the relevant stakeholders."
Six months later, Dyson has attended fourteen meetings.
Completed three risk assessments.
Produced a business case.
Participated in a lessons learned exercise.
And been asked to demonstrate how his proposed invention aligns with the current vacuum cleaner operating model.
The project is eventually rejected.
Reason:
Insufficient alignment with established best practice.
Meanwhile, Martin receives an award for demonstrating strong governance during the innovation process.
FUCKING BRILLIANT.
And yes, Dyson's actual invention involved serious engineering, experimentation and learning from existing technology.
The point isn't that he ignored everything anybody had ever learned.
The point is that he didn't accept the existing product as the final answer.
Which is precisely the distinction corporate management seems incapable of understanding.
Steve Jobs Would Have Been Put on a Performance Improvement Plan
Now imagine Steve Jobs joining a modern corporate organisation.
A man famous for challenging assumptions about how technology should look, feel and function.
He walks into a meeting.
"I think we need to rethink the way people interact with computers."
Martin smiles.
"Fantastic, Steve. We love disruptive thinking."
"I want to simplify the experience radically."
"Excellent."
"Remove unnecessary complexity."
"Absolutely."
"And challenge some of the industry's established conventions."
Martin freezes.
"Sorry, Steve. We're going to need to ensure we're following best practice."
"But the existing approach isn't good enough."
"Well, perhaps we could benchmark against our competitors."
"Why would we copy our competitors?"
"Because they're following industry standards."
"That's the problem."
Martin makes a note.
Steve demonstrating resistance to established processes.
Three weeks later, Steve is invited to a meeting with HR.
"Steve, we've had some feedback about your approach."
"What feedback?"
"Some colleagues feel you're challenging existing ways of working."
"Yes. That's literally my job."
"We absolutely encourage constructive challenge, Steve, but it's important that we remain aligned."
Aligned.
There it is again.
The corporate equivalent of telling somebody to shut the fuck up while pretending you're encouraging collaboration.
By Friday, Steve has been placed on a development plan.
Objective one:
Demonstrate greater respect for established organisational practices.
Objective two:
Improve stakeholder engagement.
Objective three:
Reduce disruptive behaviour.
And the following Monday, Kevin is promoted to Head of Innovation.
Because he attended the workshop, agreed with Martin and suggested changing the colour of the fucking PowerPoint template.
Best Practice: The Manager's Intellectual Comfort Blanket
Here's what I find particularly interesting.
When a competent person refers to best practice, they can usually explain why it exists.
They understand the underlying principles.
They know what problems it solves.
They understand its limitations.
And they can recognise when a different approach might produce a better outcome.
But when an incompetent manager refers to best practice, something very different happens.
"Why do we do it this way?"
"Because it's best practice."
"Why is it best practice?"
"Because it's the recommended approach."
"Recommended by whom?"
"The industry."
"Which part of the industry?"
"Well, it's widely recognised."
"What's the evidence?"
"We need to remain aligned with best practice."
YOU DON'T FUCKING KNOW, DO YOU?
You haven't got a clue.
You're simply repeating something you've heard because it sounds authoritative.
Best practice has become your intellectual comfort blanket.
Your emergency escape route from having to form an independent opinion.
Because if you say, "I think we should do this," somebody might ask you to justify your thinking.
But if you say, "This is industry best practice," suddenly the decision appears to have been made by some mysterious higher authority.
Who?
Nobody knows.
Where?
Somewhere.
When?
Probably at a conference Quentin attended.
And that's enough.
Apparently.
The Sacred Best-Practice Document
Every organisation has one.
A document.
Usually stored somewhere on SharePoint.
Possibly written eight years ago.
Probably approved by somebody who no longer works there.
And treated with the reverence normally reserved for ancient religious texts.
Nobody remembers who wrote it.
Nobody knows whether it's still relevant.
Nobody has checked whether it produces the best outcomes.
But everybody knows you're supposed to follow it.
Raj suggests an improvement.
"Actually, I think there's a more efficient way to do this."
Martin shakes his head.
"Unfortunately, that wouldn't align with the documented best practice."
"Why?"
"Because the document specifies the existing approach."
"Yes, but the existing approach is inefficient."
"Then perhaps we need to update the document."
"Great. Can we do that?"
"Well, we'd need to establish a working group."
"Why?"
"To review the proposed changes."
"Okay."
"And then submit them to the governance board."
"Right."
"Before seeking approval from the process owner."
"Fine."
"Who would need to consult the relevant stakeholders."
"Of course."
"And then we'd need to assess whether the revised process aligns with best practice."
FOR FUCK'S SAKE.
We've created a process for changing a process that requires us to follow the process we're trying to change.
It's corporate bureaucracy eating its own fucking tail.
The Best-Practice Consultant
Of course, sometimes management isn't confident enough to identify best practice itself.
So it hires a consultant.
An external expert.
Somebody who charges £1,500 a day to explain how other companies operate.
Meet Dominic.
Dominic has worked for several major consultancies.
He wears expensive shoes.
He carries a laptop that costs more than Colin's car.
And he uses the phrase industry-leading framework approximately seventeen times per hour.
Dominic spends three weeks interviewing employees.
He asks how the department works.
What the problems are.
Where the inefficiencies exist.
The employees explain everything.
In considerable detail.
Dominic takes notes.
Then disappears for two weeks.
When he returns, he presents his findings to senior management.
"Our analysis has identified significant opportunities to improve operational efficiency through greater process standardisation."
Martin is impressed.
Stuart nods enthusiastically.
Quentin asks a question containing the words enterprise architecture maturity.
Dominic clicks to the next slide.
"Our recommendation is to adopt a best-practice operating model."
Fantastic.
And what does that involve?
Well, essentially, doing all the things the employees suggested during the interviews.
Except now they're presented in a professionally designed PowerPoint.
With diagrams.
And arrows.
And a maturity model.
And a fucking invoice for £45,000.
Management is delighted.
"Some really valuable insights."
YES.
THEY WERE VALUABLE WHEN YOUR OWN EMPLOYEES TOLD YOU THE SAME FUCKING THING SIX MONTHS AGO.
But apparently, an idea only becomes credible once it's been repeated by somebody wearing a suit and charging four figures a day.
The Innovation Department That Doesn't Innovate
Some companies actually employ people specifically to encourage innovation.
Innovation Managers.
Heads of Innovation.
Directors of Digital Transformation.
Chief Innovation Officers.
Wonderful titles.
Very impressive.
But what do they actually do?
Well, they organise workshops.
They attend conferences.
They publish thought leadership articles.
They develop innovation frameworks.
They create innovation strategies.
They launch innovation portals where employees can submit ideas.
And then?
The ideas enter an approval process.
Naturally.
First, the idea is reviewed.
Then categorised.
Then assessed.
Then prioritised.
Then evaluated against the innovation framework.
Then considered by the innovation steering committee.
Then referred to the relevant business owner.
Then subjected to a feasibility assessment.
And finally, after approximately nine months, somebody sends the employee an email.
"Thank you for your innovative suggestion. Unfortunately, we're unable to progress this idea at the present time."
Why?
"Because it doesn't align with our current operating model."
IT'S AN INNOVATION IDEA, YOU FUCKING CABBAGE.
IT'S NOT SUPPOSED TO BE IDENTICAL TO YOUR CURRENT OPERATING MODEL.
THAT'S THE ENTIRE FUCKING POINT.
But don't worry.
The innovation department has achieved its annual target.
Forty-seven ideas submitted.
Twelve innovation workshops delivered.
Three thought leadership articles published.
And absolutely fuck all changed.
Outstanding.
Best Practice Versus Better Practice
Here's a thought.
What if we stopped treating best practice as the final destination?
What if we treated it as the best approach currently known, under particular circumstances?
Because that's what it should be.
A useful reference point.
A collection of lessons learned.
A foundation for making informed decisions.
Not an instruction to stop thinking.
If somebody proposes a different approach, ask questions.
Why might it be better?
What evidence supports it?
What risks does it introduce?
How could we test it?
What would success look like?
Can we experiment safely?
Can we learn something?
That's how improvement happens.
Not by blindly ignoring established knowledge.
And not by blindly worshipping it.
But by understanding it well enough to recognise when something better might be possible.
Because the greatest innovations often emerge when somebody looks at an accepted approach and asks:
"Why are we still doing it like that?"
Unfortunately, in corporate life, that question is frequently interpreted as a behavioural problem.
Quentin's Best-Practice Masterclass
Naturally, Quentin has opinions on this subject.
Strong opinions.
He's a Principal Architect.
He's attended conferences.
He's collected lanyards.
He's spoken to thought leaders.
And he's very passionate about architectural best practice.
So he arranges a meeting.
Subject:
Driving Best Practice Through Architectural Governance.
Forty-five minutes.
Fourteen attendees.
Quentin opens.
"It's important that we establish a consistent approach to are architectural standards."
OUR, QUENTIN.
FUCKING OUR.
"We need to ensure all teams follow recognised best practice."
Excellent.
Raj raises his hand.
"Can we clarify which standards we're referring to and whether they're appropriate for our specific environment?"
Quentin looks slightly irritated.
"Well, these are established industry approaches."
"Yes, but our environment has some unusual requirements. We might need to adapt them."
"Raj, we need to be careful about deviating from best practice."
"Of course. I'm suggesting we assess the requirements and make an informed decision."
"Right. Well, perhaps we should take that offline."
And there it is.
The universal corporate emergency exit.
Take it offline.
Translation:
PLEASE STOP ASKING QUESTIONS I CAN'T FUCKING ANSWER.
The meeting ends.
Quentin sends a follow-up email.
"Thank you for attending today's productive discussion. Are next steps are to ensure continued alignment with industry best practice."
Somebody should really confiscate his fucking keyboard.
The Real Reason Managers Love Best Practice
Now we arrive at the uncomfortable part.
I suspect some managers love best practice for a very simple reason.
It reduces their personal exposure.
If they make an original decision and it goes wrong, they might be held accountable.
They might have to explain their reasoning.
They might have to acknowledge that they made a mistake.
But if they follow established best practice and things go wrong?
Well, they followed best practice.
What more could they have done?
It's the perfect corporate defence mechanism.
Nobody can accuse you of taking unnecessary risks.
Nobody can accuse you of challenging established standards.
Nobody can accuse you of making an unconventional decision.
And, most importantly, nobody can accuse you of having an original fucking thought.
You can spend an entire career following approved frameworks, attending governance meetings and repeating industry terminology without ever having to demonstrate independent judgement.
And somehow, this can be mistaken for leadership.
But leadership isn't simply knowing which rule to follow.
It's understanding why the rule exists.
When it matters.
When it doesn't.
And when the situation demands something different.
That requires confidence.
Knowledge.
Curiosity.
And the willingness to accept responsibility.
Which is considerably more difficult than pointing at a document and saying:
"Sorry, that's not best practice."
The Best-Practice Paradox
Here's the contradiction that sits at the heart of this entire corporate obsession.
Every company wants to be the best.
Every company wants to lead its industry.
Every company wants to innovate.
Every company wants to differentiate itself from competitors.
But many of those same companies are terrified of doing anything differently.
They want to be exceptional by behaving conventionally.
They want to lead by following.
They want to disrupt by conforming.
They want to invent the future by copying the present.
HOW THE FUCK DOES THAT WORK?
If every organisation follows exactly the same practices, where does differentiation come from?
If nobody questions the established approach, how does that approach improve?
And if every original idea is rejected because it doesn't align with existing best practice, how does anything new ever become best practice?
Think about that.
Every established practice had to begin somewhere.
At some point, somebody tried something.
Tested something.
Changed something.
Discovered something better.
And eventually, other people adopted it.
But under the corporate interpretation of best practice, that original idea might never have been approved.
Because it wasn't already best practice.
It's a magnificent logical circle.
You can't introduce a new approach until it's recognised as best practice.
And it can't become best practice until somebody introduces it.
FUCKING GENIUS.
What I'd Do Differently
If I ran a company, I wouldn't ban best practice.
That would be ridiculous.
I'd want people to understand proven methods.
I'd want sensible standards.
I'd want appropriate governance.
I'd want employees to learn from the experience of others.
But I'd also want them to think.
Actually think.
Not simply repeat what some consultant said at a conference.
I'd want people to question processes that no longer made sense.
Challenge assumptions.
Suggest improvements.
Experiment intelligently.
And explain why they believed a different approach might work better.
I'd want managers who could distinguish between a genuinely important control and an unnecessary bureaucratic habit.
I'd want architects who understood principles rather than simply reciting frameworks.
And I'd want leaders who were comfortable admitting:
"Actually, I don't know. Let's explore it."
Because that's a considerably more intelligent response than pretending an answer exists somewhere in an industry best-practice document.
I'd reward people for improving things.
Not merely complying with them.
And if somebody came to me with an idea that challenged the established approach, I wouldn't immediately ask whether it aligned with best practice.
I'd ask:
"Is it better?"
Then we'd find out.
The Final Innovation Workshop
So imagine one final corporate innovation workshop.
Martin is presenting.
Quentin is attending.
Kevin is nodding.
Raj is sitting quietly, wondering why he agreed to come.
The opening slide reads:
Innovation Through Best-Practice Excellence.
Martin smiles.
"Today, we want to challenge everyone to think differently."
Wonderful.
"We want bold ideas."
Excellent.
"We want creativity."
Fantastic.
"We want to disrupt the status quo."
Incredible.
Raj raises his hand.
"I've got an idea that could significantly improve our delivery process."
Martin looks delighted.
"Brilliant, Raj. That's exactly what we're looking for."
"It would involve changing the existing workflow and removing some unnecessary approval stages."
Martin's smile disappears.
"Well, we'd need to ensure that aligns with best practice."
Raj pauses.
"Okay. What if the current best practice isn't actually the best approach for us?"
Silence.
Quentin shifts uncomfortably.
Kevin stops nodding.
Martin looks towards the facilitator.
"Perhaps we should take that offline."
Of course.
The workshop continues.
Three hours later, the group has generated forty-two ideas.
Forty-one involve doing exactly what the company already does.
The remaining idea has been rejected for insufficient alignment with established practices.
Martin closes the session.
"Some really fantastic blue-sky thinking today, everyone."
Kevin applauds.
Quentin announces that he'll be attending another innovation conference in London.
And Raj quietly returns to his desk to do some actual fucking work.
The following morning, management publishes an announcement.
Our Commitment to Innovation: Challenging Convention and Embracing New Ways of Working.
Below it, in smaller print:
All proposed changes must comply with existing best-practice frameworks.
And there, ladies and gentlemen, is modern corporate innovation in all its glory.
THINK OUTSIDE THE BOX.
BUT DON'T FUCKING LEAVE IT.
AND FOR GOD'S SAKE, MAKE SURE IT'S AN INDUSTRY-APPROVED BOX.