A Better Way

Employee Rewards: Keep Your Fucking Voucher and Pay Me Properly

There's a peculiar obsession in corporate life with rewarding employees using absolutely anything other than money.

Points. Vouchers. Appreciation cards. Star awards. Recognition badges. Certificates. Employee-of-the-month schemes.

Entire departments appear to have been established to devise increasingly elaborate ways of saying "well done" without actually improving anyone's bank balance.

And the remarkable thing is that some employees absolutely fucking love it.

They collect their points, display their certificates and proudly announce that they've received a Bronze Excellence Award for demonstrating outstanding commitment to the company's core values.

Congratulations, Kevin.

You've worked your arse off all quarter and they've given you enough points to buy an electric toothbrush.

Try not to spend it all at once.

Welcome to the corporate arcade

Some organisations have reward platforms where managers can award employees points for exceptional performance.

You do something brilliant, somebody recognises it, and a little notification arrives informing you that you've earned 250 points.

Fantastic.

What can I buy?

Well, after navigating a website that looks like it was designed by someone who last experienced the internet in 2006, you discover that your points can be exchanged for a carefully curated selection of retail vouchers.

Amazon. Tesco. John Lewis. Perhaps a restaurant voucher if you're feeling particularly adventurous.

It's essentially a corporate version of an amusement arcade.

You spend months demonstrating exceptional performance, collect your little tokens and eventually exchange them for something from the prize counter.

Except instead of winning tickets by playing the penny-pusher machine, you've spent three months delivering a complex project under considerable pressure.

And your prize?

A £20 Amazon voucher.

Brilliant.

I've always wanted to know what my professional expertise was worth in units of discounted household appliances.

I can actually buy things myself

Here's something companies might find surprising.

I'm an adult.

I have a bank account. I have access to the internet. I understand how shops work.

If I want something from Amazon, I can go to Amazon and buy it.

If I want a bottle of wine from Tesco, I can go to Tesco and buy one.

I don't need to complete an outstanding piece of work, receive managerial approval, accumulate 4,000 Excellence Points and navigate a corporate rewards portal to acquire a fucking toothbrush.

And yet organisations behave as though they've bestowed some extraordinary gift upon you.

"We'd like to recognise your exceptional contribution with a £25 retail voucher!"

Thank you.

I shall treasure this moment forever.

Perhaps I'll frame the email and hang it above the kettle.

Or perhaps I'll spend the voucher on toilet roll, because apparently that's what outstanding professional achievement looks like in 2026.

The appreciation card

Then there are appreciation cards.

These are particularly special.

Someone sends you a colourful digital card thanking you for going above and beyond.

It might contain a little star, a motivational slogan and a message explaining how your contribution demonstrates the company's values.

"Thank you for consistently demonstrating excellence, collaboration and customer focus!"

Lovely.

Now, here's a question.

If my contribution was so exceptional, why not reward me with something I actually value?

Money.

Time off.

A meaningful improvement in my working conditions.

Instead, I've received a digital picture of a fucking star.

And before anyone accuses me of being ungrateful, I'm perfectly capable of appreciating genuine thanks.

A sincere message from someone I've helped can mean a lot.

But that's different from an organisation building an entire recognition programme around the distribution of electronic greetings cards.

If you've got a problem with employee motivation, perhaps the answer isn't to introduce a new range of animated badges.

Perhaps it's to ask why people aren't feeling valued in the first place.

And Kevin has won another fucking award

Of course, no corporate reward programme would be complete without an awards ceremony.

Star Performer. Outstanding Contributor. Values Champion. Collaboration Hero.

There's an award for practically everything.

At some point, I fully expect to see someone receive a Platinum Excellence Certificate for demonstrating exceptional competence when replying to emails.

And you know who's going to win.

Kevin.

Kevin has been nominated by Sandra for his outstanding contribution to the quarterly stakeholder engagement initiative.

He's absolutely delighted.

He's updated his LinkedIn profile.

He's thanked his manager, his colleagues and possibly his parents.

He's even included a photograph of himself holding the certificate.

"Truly humbled to receive this recognition."

Humbled?

Kevin, mate.

You've been given a laminated piece of paper for attending meetings.

You're not collecting a Nobel Prize.

But perhaps I'm being unfair.

Maybe the recognition genuinely means something to him.

And that's fine.

I just can't help wondering whether Kevin would be quite so enthusiastic if somebody offered him a choice between his certificate and an extra £2,000 in his salary.

I suspect the certificate might suddenly lose some of its emotional significance.

Hit your sales target and we'll take you to Turkey!

Now we arrive at one of my personal favourites.

The company incentive trip.

You've seen these.

"Hit your annual sales target and you could join us for an exclusive all-expenses-paid trip to Turkey!"

Turkey.

Wonderful.

Beautiful country. Fantastic food. Lovely weather.

Absolutely nothing against Turkey.

But there's a small problem.

I'd have to go with you lot.

I've spent the entire year working towards an ambitious sales target, dealing with customers, chasing opportunities, managing deadlines and helping the company generate revenue.

And my reward is to spend several days socialising with the same people I've been working with all year.

In another fucking country.

Who came up with this?

Imagine winning a holiday in a competition and then discovering the prize includes compulsory attendance by your line manager, the regional sales director and Kevin from Business Development.

I'd be asking for the cash alternative before they'd finished reading out my name.

And there's always a promotional video.

Smiling employees beside a swimming pool. People clinking glasses. Someone wearing a company-branded polo shirt while standing on a yacht.

"An unforgettable experience!"

I'm sure it would be.

Although perhaps not for the reasons you intended.

Here's a revolutionary idea.

If I've generated enough revenue to justify an expensive overseas reward trip, give me £5,000 and let me decide where I want to go.

Perhaps I'll visit Turkey.

Perhaps I'll go somewhere else.

Perhaps I'll stay at home and spend the money on something completely unrelated to work.

The important point is that it's my reward.

Not another corporate event disguised as a holiday.

Why are companies so terrified of giving people money?

This is the bit I genuinely struggle to understand.

Companies spend enormous amounts of time discussing employee engagement, motivation, retention and recognition.

They commission surveys. They organise workshops. They introduce reward platforms. They create elaborate frameworks for celebrating exceptional performance.

And somehow, after all that effort, they conclude that the answer is a £15 voucher and a digital certificate.

Have we considered asking employees what they actually want?

Because I suspect a significant number would give a remarkably straightforward answer.

More money.

More time off.

Better working conditions.

Greater flexibility.

Perhaps the occasional opportunity to finish work without being invited to another fucking engagement initiative.

Now, I appreciate that money isn't the only thing that motivates people.

Some genuinely value public recognition. Others enjoy experiences, gifts or opportunities to develop their careers.

Fine.

But if you're going to reward someone, why not give them a choice?

And if an employee has consistently delivered exceptional value over a sustained period, perhaps the conversation should move beyond whether they've earned enough points for a Tesco voucher.

Perhaps it's time to discuss their salary.

The annual pay review is particularly entertaining

This is where corporate reward systems become genuinely absurd.

You've had a fantastic year.

You've delivered projects. Supported colleagues. Solved difficult problems. Taken on additional responsibilities.

Your manager agrees.

"Outstanding contribution this year. You've really gone above and beyond."

Excellent.

"So, regarding your salary increase..."

Here we go.

"Unfortunately, budgets are extremely tight."

Of course they are.

"However, we'd like to recognise your contribution through our employee appreciation programme."

And there it is.

You've gone above and beyond.

The company has gone above and beyond to avoid paying you for it.

But don't worry.

There's a shiny new recognition badge waiting in your inbox.

Perhaps you can show it to your mortgage provider.

"Good morning. I'd like to make an additional payment using my Gold Collaboration Award."

I'm sure they'll be delighted.

I'm probably an ungrateful bastard

Now, I should acknowledge something.

Perhaps I'm simply difficult to please.

Somebody gives me a voucher and I complain that it isn't money.

Somebody gives me an award and I complain that it's meaningless.

Somebody offers me a trip abroad and I complain that I don't want to go with my colleagues.

I'm starting to sound like the sort of person who could win a Ferrari and complain that it's the wrong colour.

But there's a distinction.

I'm not against appreciation.

I'm against organisations confusing symbolic recognition with meaningful reward.

If a colleague takes the time to thank me for helping them, I appreciate it.

If my manager recognises that I've done a good job, fantastic.

If somebody unexpectedly gives me a voucher as a small gesture of thanks, that's a nice thing to do.

But when organisations create elaborate systems of points, prizes and certificates while simultaneously telling employees there's no budget for meaningful pay increases, I think we're entitled to question the priorities.

And if you're offering me a holiday as a reward for exceptional performance, I don't think it's unreasonable to want to choose who I spend it with.

Particularly when Kevin's invited.

Here's an idea: Ask us what we actually value

Imagine a company introducing a revolutionary employee reward programme.

No points.

No badges.

No elaborate online catalogue featuring scented candles and kitchen appliances.

Instead, when somebody does something exceptional, the company asks:

"What would you actually value as a reward?"

Perhaps it's a bonus.

Perhaps it's an extra day off.

Perhaps it's a meaningful development opportunity.

Perhaps it's public recognition.

Perhaps it's simply a genuine thank-you and the freedom to get on with their work.

Different people value different things.

Which is precisely why forcing everyone through the same corporate reward machine is such a strange approach.

And while we're at it, let's stop pretending that a £25 voucher is an adequate substitute for fair pay.

It's a nice gesture.

It's not a compensation strategy.

Keep the points. I'll take the money.

Ultimately, I go to work for a fairly straightforward reason.

To earn a living.

I want to do interesting work, develop my skills, contribute something useful and work with people I respect.

But let's not pretend that money is some embarrassing little detail we're all supposed to ignore while celebrating the company's exciting new recognition platform.

Money matters.

Time matters.

Being treated like an adult matters.

And if I've genuinely delivered something exceptional, I'd rather have a conversation about my pay, my progression or my working conditions than receive another email informing me that I've earned 500 Appreciation Points.

I can buy my own toothbrush.

I can book my own holiday.

And if I want a bottle of wine from Tesco, I don't need Kevin to nominate me for demonstrating outstanding synergy.

So by all means, thank people.

Recognise their contributions.

Celebrate good work.

But don't confuse handing someone a voucher with genuinely rewarding them.

And please, stop offering me holidays with my colleagues.

I've already spent enough time with Kevin.

#Corporate Fuckery