Great Place to Work: According to Who, Exactly?
Every year, companies across the country perform a remarkable act of corporate self-delusion. They spend twelve months treating their employees like shit, then send out a survey asking whether everyone is happy.
It's called the Great Place to Work Survey.
Great Place to Work. What a fucking name.
It's rather like opening a restaurant called Absolutely Delicious, serving up Horse Shit Surprise, and then asking customers to score how it tastes.
"How would you rate your dining experience?"
Well, I've just eaten a plate of horse shit, so not particularly highly.
"Would you recommend us to friends and family?"
Only the ones I fucking hate.
"Is there anything we could do to improve your experience?"
Yes. Stop serving horse shit.
"Thank you for your valuable feedback. We're committed to culinary excellence and will be reviewing our menu as part of our ongoing customer satisfaction strategy."
JUST STOP SERVING FUCKING HORSE SHIT.
And that's the employee engagement survey in a nutshell. Management already knows what's coming out of the kitchen. They're the ones cooking the fucking horse shit. But rather than change the menu, they'd prefer to measure how unhappy everyone is about eating it.
Then they'll form a working group.
Your Voice Matters!
The invitation arrives, usually accompanied by a photograph of five suspiciously happy people laughing at a laptop.
"We want to hear your voice!"
Do you? Are you absolutely fucking sure?
Because I've got quite a lot to say, and I suspect the person reading it is going to need a stiff drink and possibly a different career.
"Your honest feedback helps us create a supportive, inclusive and empowering workplace where everyone can thrive."
Beautiful. Absolutely fucking beautiful.
Meanwhile, twenty people have left in six months, morale is somewhere beneath the floorboards, and the remaining employees are wondering whether they can afford to resign without selling a kidney.
But apparently, management needs a survey to understand how things are going.
Well, pull up a fucking chair.
Do you have confidence in senior leadership?
Oh, this is a beauty.
"Do you believe senior leaders have the skills and capabilities required to run the organisation effectively?"
No.
Actually, can I have a stronger option?
Because Strongly Disagree doesn't adequately convey the sheer fucking disbelief I experience watching these people attempt to run a business.
Where's Are You Taking the Fucking Piss?
Or I Wouldn't Trust These People to Organise a Piss-Up in a Brewery?
We've had restructures, disappearing budgets, contradictory instructions and enough strategic transformation programmes to transform the company into a fucking Rubik's Cube.
Management spends half its time announcing exciting initiatives and the other half quietly abandoning the initiatives it announced six months earlier.
And when everything inevitably goes wrong, they organise a meeting to discuss why nobody is delivering.
Perhaps because everybody's in your fucking meetings.
But sure. Let's talk about leadership capability.
I once worked with people whose ability to make a sensible decision was so questionable that I genuinely wondered how they'd managed to get dressed that morning without a steering committee.
And now I'm supposed to express confidence in them?
I'd have more confidence in a drunk chimpanzee operating a nuclear submarine.
At least the chimpanzee wouldn't describe crashing it as an exciting opportunity for maritime transformation.
Do you believe you're paid fairly?
No.
Next question.
Actually, hang on. This one deserves some attention.
The company knows what it pays me. It knows what the market pays. It knows how many responsibilities I've taken on and how many experienced employees have fucked off to work somewhere else.
Yet somehow, it needs an anonymous survey to establish whether money might be an issue.
Really?
You need a fucking questionnaire for that?
Twenty people have left in six months.
Twenty.
And management starts talking about "unexpected attrition".
Unexpected?
What were you expecting? A fucking waiting list?
Perhaps people are leaving because another company has offered them better pay, better conditions and the exciting possibility of working somewhere that doesn't treat them like a disposable printer cartridge.
But I'm sure Sandra can organise a workshop.
That'll fix it.
Would you recommend this company to friends and family?
Absolutely.
If I fucking hated them.
If somebody had stolen my car, kicked my dog, insulted my family and spent fifteen years making my life miserable, I might consider recommending they apply.
"Looking for a new job? Have I got the place for you!"
"What's it like?"
"Well, the pay's shit, management is questionable, morale is through the floor and half the workforce is planning an escape."
"Sounds awful."
"Oh, it is. But there's a fantastic employee rewards programme. If you work exceptionally hard, you might earn enough points for a £10 shopping voucher."
And I'm supposed to recommend this place to people I actually care about?
What sort of fucking psychopath would do that?
"Hi, Mum. I know you've always supported me and given me everything, so I've found you a wonderful opportunity to spend forty hours a week questioning every decision you've ever made."
No.
If I wouldn't recommend the company, I wouldn't recommend it.
That's not a failure of employee engagement.
That's a failure of the fucking company.
Do you feel valued?
Another masterpiece.
"Do you feel your contribution is recognised and appreciated?"
Well, let's see.
I've delivered the work, solved the problems, taken on additional responsibilities, helped colleagues and rescued projects that were heading spectacularly towards disaster.
And at the end of the year, management asked me to write my own performance review, document my own achievements and find several people willing to confirm that I'm not a complete fucking liability.
So do I feel valued?
Not particularly.
But I did receive an email thanking me for my dedication.
It had a lovely picture of a mountain on it.
And Kevin got a Gold Collaboration Award for organising a meeting that should have been an email.
So perhaps I'm being ungrateful.
Maybe I should stop expecting actual recognition and start appreciating the fucking clip art.
Do you feel your opinions are listened to?
This might be the most unintentionally hilarious question in the entire survey.
"Do you feel comfortable expressing your opinions and challenging decisions?"
Well, I've just told you that management is incompetent, the pay is rubbish and I wouldn't recommend the company to somebody I actively despised.
So clearly, expressing my opinions isn't the problem.
The problem is that nobody appears to give a flying fuck what I think.
And there's a rather important difference between asking people for their opinions and actually listening to them.
You can ask employees what they think all day long. You can create feedback channels, listening sessions, open forums, engagement platforms and anonymous suggestion boxes.
But if the response to every uncomfortable truth is another presentation explaining why management is already doing a brilliant job, you're not listening.
You're collecting complaints.
There's a difference.
Your responses are completely anonymous
"Please remember that all survey responses are completely anonymous."
Wonderful.
So I can be honest?
"Absolutely!"
No consequences?
"None whatsoever!"
Management won't know who said what?
"Individual responses will never be shared."
Excellent.
Then why the fuck are you asking for my department, job level, business unit, length of service and location?
"An employee in the technical department, at senior consultant level, with approximately seven years of service, has expressed some rather strong concerns about leadership."
Really?
How mysterious.
Perhaps we should call Sherlock Holmes.
Now, properly administered surveys can genuinely protect anonymity. That's not the issue.
The issue is that companies with a trust problem seem genuinely surprised when employees don't trust them.
Karen from HR sends another email.
"Please feel completely safe to share your honest thoughts!"
Thanks, Karen.
Nothing makes me feel safer than being repeatedly assured I won't be punished for telling the truth.
It's rather like boarding an aeroplane and having the pilot announce:
"Good afternoon, passengers. Just to reassure everyone, there's absolutely no reason to believe we're going to crash."
Well, there fucking is now.
The compulsory voluntary survey
"Participation is entirely voluntary."
Excellent.
Then I won't bother.
Three days later:
"Just a friendly reminder to complete your engagement survey!"
Two days after that:
"We're currently at 68% participation. Let's see if we can reach 100%!"
Then Sandra posts in Teams.
"Come on, everyone! Your voice really matters!"
Then your manager mentions it during a meeting.
Then Karen sends another reminder.
Then Kevin announces he's completed his survey and encourages everyone to participate because it's "a fantastic opportunity to shape our collective future".
Kevin would complete a satisfaction survey after being kicked in the bollocks and describe the experience as a valuable opportunity for personal growth.
And the really extraordinary thing is that management becomes obsessed with the participation rate.
"We achieved 96% engagement!"
No.
You achieved 96% survey completion.
That's not the same fucking thing.
A prison could achieve 100% participation in a prisoner satisfaction survey.
It wouldn't suddenly become Centre Parcs.
I was once asked to be a Great Place to Work Champion
Now, this is where the whole thing becomes particularly fucking ridiculous.
I was once asked to become a Great Place to Work Champion.
Me.
A Great Place to Work Champion.
For a company I thought was run by a collection of complete cunts.
I'm not entirely sure what criteria they used to select me, but I can only assume somebody had suffered a serious head injury.
Perhaps they'd mistaken my ability to identify corporate bullshit for enthusiasm about participating in it.
"Would you like to become a Great Place to Work Champion?"
Would I?
Would I like to spend my spare time enthusiastically promoting an organisation I can barely tolerate?
Would I like to encourage my colleagues to celebrate a workplace that regularly makes me question whether humanity was a terrible evolutionary mistake?
Would I like to become an unpaid ambassador for management decisions I think are fucking idiotic?
No, thanks.
That's rather like asking a vegetarian to become the official spokesperson for a slaughterhouse.
Or asking a passenger on the Titanic to become the ship's Safety Ambassador.
"Come on, everyone! Let's celebrate what a fantastic voyage we're having!"
Mate, the fucking boat's sinking.
And I genuinely wondered what they expected me to do.
Walk around telling everyone how wonderful the company was?
Encourage people to complete surveys?
Organise engagement activities?
Perhaps I could have designed a poster.
GREAT PLACE TO WORK!
Terms and conditions apply. Actual experience may differ substantially from promotional materials.
I suppose I could have accepted the role and used it as an opportunity to tell management exactly what I thought.
But something tells me that wasn't quite what they had in mind.
They wanted a champion.
What they nearly got was a fucking whistleblower with a badge.
The results are in!
Eventually, the results arrive.
And they're fucking dreadful.
Employees don't trust leadership. People feel underpaid. Morale is low. Confidence in the future is questionable. And a significant proportion of the workforce wouldn't recommend the company to someone they liked.
An ordinary person might examine these results and conclude that something has gone spectacularly wrong.
But corporate management doesn't operate like ordinary people.
It operates through PowerPoint.
"Thank you to everyone who participated in our recent engagement survey. We really appreciate your honest and open feedback."
Here it comes.
"While there are some encouraging results, we've also identified several exciting opportunities for improvement."
Exciting?
People are fucking miserable, Sandra.
That's not exciting.
That's a problem.
But apparently, corporate life has developed a remarkable ability to turn every negative into a positive.
Low morale is an opportunity.
Poor leadership is an opportunity.
Inadequate pay is an opportunity.
High staff turnover is an opportunity.
At this rate, if the building collapses and kills half the management team, Karen will probably describe it as an exciting opportunity to optimise office space.
And Kevin will volunteer to lead the reconstruction workstream.
We hear you!
Ah, yes.
The three most dangerous words in corporate communication.
"We hear you."
Do you?
Because I'm fairly sure I said the pay was shit, management was incompetent and half the workforce wanted to escape.
But your response appears to involve a wellbeing newsletter and a new employee engagement committee.
"We recognise that some colleagues would welcome greater clarity around our strategic direction."
No.
They think management is fucking useless.
"We acknowledge that reward and recognition remains an important area of focus."
They want more money.
"We're committed to exploring innovative approaches to improving the employee experience."
PAY THEM MORE FUCKING MONEY.
"To support this journey, we'll be launching a series of employee listening workshops."
OH, FUCK OFF.
You asked everyone what they thought.
They told you.
Now you're organising workshops to ask them what they meant?
What part of "the pay is shit" requires further clarification?
Would you like me to draw a fucking diagram?
Perhaps Abdul could prepare a technical architecture document explaining the relationship between inadequate salaries and employees leaving.
Although, knowing Abdul, that might take six months and involve seventeen appendices.
The employee engagement action plan
Naturally, the survey can't simply end with management acknowledging the problems and doing something about them.
That would be dangerously efficient.
Instead, we need an action plan.
Not just any action plan.
A People Engagement and Cultural Transformation Roadmap.
With workstreams.
Milestones.
Accountable owners.
Quarterly reviews.
And a PowerPoint presentation featuring five people standing on a mountain with the word TOGETHER underneath.
Sandra takes ownership of wellbeing.
Karen leads communications.
Kevin volunteers to become an Employee Engagement Champion.
Of course he fucking does.
Kevin has been waiting his entire professional life for this moment.
He now has a badge on his email signature.
EMPLOYEE ENGAGEMENT CHAMPION
Which is unfortunate, because most of the employees would happily engage in pushing Kevin into a skip.
Not that they would.
They've all completed their mandatory workplace conduct training.
Meanwhile, Raj quietly asks whether there's any budget for salary increases.
Silence.
"That's a really important question, Raj."
Of course it is.
"Compensation is something we're continuing to review as part of our wider reward strategy."
Translation:
No.
There's no fucking money.
But there might be another voucher.
The problem is apparently the employees
Here's where the whole thing becomes genuinely insulting.
When the survey results are sufficiently bad, some organisations stop asking what's wrong with the company and start asking what's wrong with the employees.
"How can we encourage a more positive mindset?"
Perhaps by giving people something to be positive about?
"We need employees to take greater ownership of our culture."
Perhaps management needs to take ownership of its fucking decisions?
"We want everyone to demonstrate a constructive attitude."
Perhaps stop treating legitimate criticism like a personality defect?
And then comes my personal favourite.
"We all have a responsibility to make this a great place to work."
Oh, do we?
Do I set the salary budgets?
No.
Do I decide the company's strategy?
No.
Do I appoint senior management?
No.
Do I determine staffing levels?
No.
Can I authorise meaningful changes to the things employees are complaining about?
No.
But apparently, we're all equally responsible for the situation.
That's rather like the captain of the Titanic gathering the passengers after hitting the iceberg and announcing:
"Look, I think we all need to take ownership of this situation."
No, Captain.
You drove the fucking boat.
I was eating dinner.
The Great Place to Work badge
And then there's the obsession with awards and certifications.
A company receives some kind of workplace recognition and immediately announces it across LinkedIn.
"We're absolutely delighted to be recognised as a Great Place to Work!"
Congratulations.
I'm sure the certificate looks lovely.
Perhaps you could hang it above the exit so the departing employees can admire it on their way out.
Now, genuine workplace awards can reflect genuine achievements.
But if your employees are telling you they're underpaid, unhappy and considering leaving, perhaps waving a shiny certificate around isn't quite the victory you think it is.
Imagine the Horse Shit Surprise Restaurant receiving an award for Outstanding Customer Experience.
The chef proudly hangs it on the wall.
The customers are still vomiting.
But at least the branding looks fantastic.
And Kevin's already posted about it on LinkedIn.
"Absolutely humbled to be part of such an incredible culinary journey. Proud to work alongside so many passionate colleagues who consistently go above and beyond."
Kevin, you've got horse shit on your chin.
Perhaps I'm just a miserable bastard
Now, I appreciate that my responses to these surveys might suggest I'm not the most cheerful employee in the organisation.
I'm unlikely to tick Strongly Agree when asked whether senior leadership inspires me.
I'm not going to pretend I'm delighted with my salary if I think it's inadequate.
And I'm certainly not recommending a company to friends and family simply because Karen would like a higher advocacy score.
But here's the thing.
If you ask people for honest feedback, you have to accept that some of it might be unpleasant.
That's the entire fucking point.
And employees who take the time to explain what's wrong aren't necessarily negative troublemakers.
Sometimes they're the people who still care enough to tell you.
The really dangerous employees aren't always the ones writing angry survey responses.
They're the ones who've stopped bothering.
The ones who don't believe anything will change.
The ones quietly updating their CVs, attending interviews and waiting for the right opportunity to leave.
They won't write three paragraphs explaining why management has failed.
They'll just resign.
And then management will describe their departure as "unexpected attrition".
Unexpected?
Twenty people have already left.
What were you expecting?
A fucking queue to get back in?
Here's a radical suggestion
If you want to know whether your company is a great place to work, stop obsessing over the survey score and look at what actually happens inside it.
Are people paid fairly?
Are they managed competently?
Do they have manageable workloads?
Are good employees recognised?
Are problems dealt with?
Do people trust the leadership?
And when employees raise legitimate concerns, does anyone actually fucking listen?
Because you don't need a 47-question survey, a consultancy report and three employee listening workshops to understand that people don't enjoy being treated badly.
You don't need an Engagement Champion.
You don't need a Cultural Transformation Roadmap.
You don't need Sandra organising Wellbeing Wednesday.
And you certainly don't need Kevin wandering around with a lanyard that says PEOPLE FIRST.
You need to stop serving Horse Shit Surprise and wondering why everyone keeps leaving the restaurant.
Same time next year?
And of course, twelve months later, another email arrives.
"Your voice matters! It's time for our annual employee engagement survey!"
Brilliant.
Here we fucking go again.
"Do you have confidence in senior leadership?"
Still no.
"Do you feel fairly rewarded?"
Still no.
"Would you recommend this organisation as a great place to work?"
Only to someone I genuinely fucking despise.
"Do you believe the company acts on employee feedback?"
Well, let's see.
Last year, I told you management was incompetent, salaries were inadequate and morale was collapsing.
You responded by creating an engagement committee, launching a wellbeing newsletter and giving Kevin a badge.
Bob's still a cunt.
Karen's still turning every straightforward problem into a twelve-stage approval process.
And Kevin's just been promoted to Senior Employee Engagement Ambassador, presumably because there was nobody left willing to attend the fucking meetings.
Meanwhile, another twenty people have left.
But don't worry.
Sandra has some fantastic news.
Survey participation is up 3%.
Apparently, we're making excellent progress.
And the Horse Shit Surprise Restaurant has just announced an exciting new menu.
Horse Shit Surprise with Seasonal Vegetables.
Only £39.95.
"Would you recommend us to friends and family?"
Absolutely. Just let me know which members of my family you fucking hate.