A Better Way

Have You Tried Asking the People Who Actually Do the Fucking Job?

I recently received an email from my employer announcing an exciting update about an upcoming organisational transformation.

I've changed the names, terminology and some of the wording to protect the identity of the company and those involved. However, the context, underlying message and general level of corporate bollocks remain faithful to the original.

I'd encourage you to read the email in full before continuing.

Then I'm going to pull it apart in the only way I know how.

Because this, ladies and gentlemen, is absolute fucking gold.


The Email

Subject: An Exciting Update on Our Organisational Transformation

Dear colleagues,

Following our recent business briefing, I wanted to share an update on the progress we're making as we prepare to transition into our new operating model next year.

Over the past few weeks, our senior leadership team has been engaging with key stakeholders across the organisation to explore how our newly aligned business functions can support our strategic ambitions and accelerate future growth.

The conversations have been incredibly positive, with a shared recognition that our evolving structure presents a significant opportunity to strengthen collaboration, enhance delivery excellence and unlock the full potential of our collective capabilities.

Alongside these discussions, our transformation and organisational effectiveness teams have been developing the framework for a more integrated operating model, bringing together our commercial divisions, specialist service functions, business development teams and operational leadership.

To support this important work, a selection of senior representatives will participate in a series of strategic workshops focused on three key priorities: Growth, Performance and Capability.

These sessions will help establish the foundations of our future organisation, identify opportunities for greater alignment and determine how we can work more effectively across the business.

Once the initial workshops have concluded, we'll communicate the key outcomes, share the decisions made and outline opportunities for colleagues to contribute to the next stages of our transformation journey.

Your experience, insight and commitment will be essential as we bring our new operating model to life. We're excited about what lies ahead and look forward to working together to make this transition a success.

Further updates will follow as our plans develop.

Thank you for your continued dedication and support.

Have a fantastic weekend!

The Senior Leadership Team


Right. Where the Fuck Do We Start?

First of all, congratulations to everyone involved in producing this email. It is a magnificent achievement in the field of saying absolutely fuck all while giving the impression that something of enormous historical significance is taking place.

Several paragraphs. Hundreds of words. Enough corporate terminology to make a LinkedIn influencer spontaneously ejaculate.

And what have we learned?

Some senior managers have spoken to some other senior managers. They've all agreed that the future looks exciting. They're now arranging meetings to discuss the meetings they've already had, after which they'll tell the rest of us what's happening.

Outstanding.

Let's examine this masterpiece.

1. The Senior Leadership Team Has Been Engaging With Key Stakeholders

Well, thank fuck for that.

For a moment I was worried they might have been engaging with the people who actually do the work.

But no. They've been speaking to key stakeholders.

Who are these mysterious individuals? Presumably other senior managers, directors and executives, all sitting around expensive conference tables nodding enthusiastically while someone explains the strategic importance of collaboration.

I can almost hear the conversation.

"We need to drive growth."

"Absolutely, Richard. And capability."

"Excellent point, Simon. We mustn't forget delivery."

"Couldn't agree more. Shall we get another coffee?"

And there we have it. The future of the organisation, expertly designed by six people who haven't logged into the operational system since 2019.

Now, I appreciate that senior leaders have responsibilities. They understand budgets, commercial priorities and strategic direction. All very important.

But here's a radical fucking suggestion.

Why not speak to the people who actually do the job?

You know, the people dealing with customers, resolving problems, delivering projects, navigating broken processes and quietly keeping the business functioning while the leadership team explores its collective capabilities.

Apparently, that's a conversation for another day.

2. The Conversations Have Been Incredibly Positive

Of course they fucking have.

What did you expect?

The senior leadership team has been speaking to other senior leaders about a strategy developed by senior leaders.

And, incredibly, everyone thinks it's brilliant.

What an astonishing coincidence.

It's rather like asking six estate agents whether house prices should go up.

Or asking a group of turkeys whether Christmas should be moved to February.

Actually, that last one might produce a more meaningful discussion.

I'd be far more interested in hearing what happened when someone said:

"Excuse me, but this is a terrible idea. The current structure barely functions, nobody knows who's responsible for anything, and you've just introduced another management layer."

Was that conversation incredibly positive too?

Or did that person mysteriously disappear from the stakeholder engagement programme?

3. Unlocking the Full Potential of Our Collective Capabilities

What the actual fuck does this mean?

Seriously.

Read it again.

"Unlocking the full potential of our collective capabilities."

It's the sort of sentence you get when you feed a management consultancy brochure into a blender and pour the contents directly into Microsoft Outlook.

Why can't companies just communicate like normal human beings?

"We want to organise our teams better so we can do a better job."

There. Done.

Eleven words. Everyone understands.

Instead, we've got collective capabilities being unlocked, strategic ambitions being accelerated and delivery excellence being enhanced.

I'm surprised nobody mentioned leveraging synergies.

Perhaps they're saving that for the Christmas newsletter.

4. Growth, Performance and Capability

Three words.

In bold.

Because apparently putting three abstract nouns in bold transforms them into a business strategy.

Growth. Performance. Capability.

Fuck me. Inspirational.

Why stop there?

How about Success, Excellence and Winning?

Or Money, Customers and Doing Stuff?

These are not revolutionary concepts. They're the basic objectives of virtually every commercial organisation on the planet.

It's like a restaurant announcing an exciting new strategic framework built around three transformational pillars:

Food. Service. Eating.

And then inviting twelve senior chefs to a two-day workshop to explore the opportunities.

Just make the fucking lasagne, Kevin.

5. The Strategic Workshops

Here we go.

The workshops.

Of course there are workshops.

There are always fucking workshops.

No corporate transformation has ever taken place without a group of middle-aged executives gathering in a hotel conference room to stick coloured Post-it notes onto a wall.

There'll be a facilitator.

There'll be flipcharts.

Someone will say "blue-sky thinking".

Someone else will suggest "parking that for now".

And at least one person will insist that we need to "take a holistic view".

By lunchtime, they'll have identified seventeen opportunities, nine challenges, six strategic priorities and a critical dependency on further stakeholder engagement.

By three o'clock, someone will have drawn a triangle.

By four, that triangle will have become the foundation of the new operating model.

And by Monday morning, a PowerPoint presentation containing forty-seven slides will be circulating among people who weren't invited.

Meanwhile, back in the actual business, someone's trying to get a fucking laptop replaced.

6. Once the Workshops Have Concluded, We'll Share the Decisions Made

And there it is.

The sentence that tells you everything you need to know.

Once the workshops have concluded, we'll share the decisions made.

Read that carefully.

The important people are going to have their discussions, agree their approach and make their decisions.

Then they'll tell everyone else.

And somewhere after that, apparently, the ordinary employees will have an opportunity to contribute.

How wonderfully inclusive.

It's like inviting someone to help design their new house after you've poured the foundations, built the walls and installed the kitchen.

"Your input is incredibly important to us, David."

"Brilliant. I'd quite like a downstairs toilet."

"Unfortunately, David, the toilet strategy has already been aligned with our overarching property transformation framework. But we'd welcome your thoughts on the colour of the hand towels."

This is the bit that genuinely pisses me off.

Not because senior managers shouldn't make decisions. Of course they should.

But because the people who experience the problems every single day should be among the first people you consult when you're trying to solve them.

Not the last.

Not once you've already established your strategic direction.

Not when you need enthusiastic volunteers to help implement something they had absolutely no say in designing.

At the beginning.

It's hardly a revolutionary concept.

7. Your Experience, Insight and Commitment Will Be Essential

Will it?

That's lovely.

When, exactly?

Because so far, the email has described senior leaders talking to senior stakeholders, senior representatives attending strategic workshops and senior management developing the future operating model.

But suddenly my experience and insight are essential.

How convenient.

Presumably my insight becomes particularly valuable once somebody needs me to implement the decisions.

And my commitment becomes essential when the new structure inevitably produces confusion, duplicated responsibilities and an entirely new collection of meetings that could have been emails.

Funny how that works.

Employees are often told they're the company's greatest asset.

Right up until the company needs to decide how that asset should operate.

Then apparently the greatest asset is a room full of directors with a flipchart.

8. Have a Fantastic Weekend!

And finally, the closing line.

Have a fantastic weekend!

Thanks, Richard.

You've just sent me an email announcing that the entire organisation is being redesigned by people I've never met, using a process I don't understand, with outcomes that haven't been explained and opportunities for involvement that haven't been defined.

But yes.

I'll have a fucking fantastic weekend.

Might even unlock the full potential of my collective capabilities by mowing the lawn.


The Actual Problem

Underneath all the sarcasm, there's a serious point here.

I don't object to organisational change. Businesses evolve. Markets change. Structures become inefficient. Sometimes things need to be reorganised.

Fine.

What I object to is the extraordinary disconnect between those making the decisions and those living with the consequences.

It's the same problem you see when wealthy politicians confidently explain the challenges facing ordinary working people, despite having little direct experience of their everyday lives.

They may understand the statistics, the budgets and the broader strategy.

But understanding something from a spreadsheet is not the same as experiencing it.

And the same applies to business.

Senior leaders might understand revenue, profitability, market positioning and resource allocation.

But do they know why a straightforward customer request takes three weeks to complete?

Do they know which internal processes waste hours of employees' time?

Do they know how many approvals are required to do something that should take ten minutes?

Do they know which systems don't work properly, which teams are stretched beyond capacity or which management decisions are actively making people's jobs harder?

Perhaps some do.

But if you genuinely want to find out, there's a remarkably simple solution.

Ask the fucking people doing the work.

And not through another anonymous employee engagement survey with seventeen questions about whether you feel empowered to bring your authentic self to work.

Actually speak to them.

Ask what works.

Ask what doesn't.

Ask what they'd change.

And here's the really difficult bit.

Listen to the answers, even when they're uncomfortable.

Now, to be fair, the email doesn't prove that nobody outside senior management has been consulted. Perhaps there have been conversations that simply weren't mentioned.

But that's rather the point.

If you're announcing an exciting, collaborative transformation, wouldn't it be sensible to explain how the people doing the work are helping to shape it?

Instead, we're told that the senior leadership team has been having incredibly positive conversations with other important people.

Fantastic.

But here's my question.

If the people at the top already knew how to make everything work better, why does so much of it need fixing in the first place?

Maybe, just maybe, the answer isn't another strategic workshop.

Maybe it's walking downstairs, sitting next to someone who actually does the job and asking:

"What makes your working day unnecessarily difficult?"

No flipcharts.

No transformation consultants.

No fucking triangles.

Just a conversation.

A better way, perhaps.

#Corporate Fuckery