A Better Way

If I Owned a Company, I'd Run It Very Differently. For a Start, I Wouldn't Employ So Many Fucking Idiots.

I've spent enough years working in corporate organisations to reach a fairly straightforward conclusion.

Running a good company really shouldn't be this fucking difficult.

And yet, somehow, enormous organisations employing thousands of people, supported by entire departments dedicated to strategy, transformation, operational excellence and employee engagement, routinely manage to make the simplest things spectacularly complicated.

They employ people and don't train them.

They promote people who can't manage.

They reward people who contribute fuck all.

They ignore the people keeping the business running.

They hold meetings to discuss why they're having too many meetings.

They send surveys asking why employees are unhappy, then organise workshops to discuss the survey results instead of fixing the things making everyone unhappy.

And when the best people eventually resign, management stands around looking genuinely astonished.

"Unfortunately, we've experienced some unexpected attrition."

Unexpected?

YOU'VE BEEN RUNNING THE PLACE LIKE A FUCKING CIRCUS, MARTIN.

The only unexpected thing is that anybody's still here.

So I've been thinking.

What if I owned a company?

What if I could build an organisation from scratch, employ the people I wanted, establish the culture and decide how the place actually operated?

Would I do things differently?

You're fucking right I would.

And the first thing I'd do is remove approximately ninety percent of the corporate bullshit.

Rule One: I Wouldn't Employ Fucking Idiots

Now, before somebody from HR starts hyperventilating into their diversity policy, let me explain.

I'm not talking about academic qualifications.

I'm not talking about whether somebody went to university.

I'm not talking about whether they've got twenty years of experience or seventeen certificates displayed on LinkedIn.

I'm talking about competence.

Common sense.

Judgement.

Curiosity.

The ability to think.

And, perhaps most importantly, the ability to recognise when you don't know something.

I'd rather employ somebody with three years of experience, a functioning brain and a genuine desire to learn than some self-important Principal Architect with forty certifications and the common sense of a retarded chicken.

Because qualifications don't automatically make somebody intelligent.

Job titles don't automatically make somebody competent.

And having spent twenty years working in an industry doesn't necessarily mean you've spent twenty years getting better at it.

Sometimes it just means you've been fucking useless for a very long time.

I've encountered people who can explain highly complex technical architecture but can't follow a basic operational process.

People who can produce a fifty-page strategy document but can't make a straightforward decision.

People who communicate with the authority of a Supreme Court judge while apparently being unable to distinguish between "are" and "our".

And these people are often treated as enormously important.

Why?

Because they've got a senior title.

Because they know the right people.

Because they're very good at sounding clever in meetings.

Well, in my company, that wouldn't be enough.

You'd have to actually be fucking useful.

I'd Hire People Properly

Recruitment would be one of the most important things we did.

Not because I'd want a seven-stage interview process involving psychometric assessments, personality colours and a presentation about where you see yourself in five years.

Quite the opposite.

I'd want to meet people.

Have a proper conversation.

Understand what they can do.

Find out what interests them.

Explore how they think.

See how they approach problems.

And establish whether they'd make the company better.

I'd read their fucking CV before the interview.

Revolutionary, I know.

I wouldn't ask somebody to spend twenty minutes explaining their employment history when they've already provided a document containing exactly that information.

I wouldn't ask why they wanted the job and expect some ridiculous declaration of lifelong devotion to my company.

They want a job.

I have a job.

Let's see whether it's a good match.

And I'd be completely honest about the role.

The responsibilities.

The salary.

The expectations.

The challenges.

The good bits.

The shit bits.

Because I wouldn't want somebody accepting a job based on a carefully manufactured fantasy.

I'd want them to know exactly what they were joining.

And if they decided it wasn't for them?

Fine.

Better to discover that during recruitment than six months later when they're sitting in an exit interview wondering why nobody told them the truth.

I'd Employ Interesting People

This is important.

I wouldn't want a company full of identical corporate personalities.

You know the type.

The relentlessly agreeable, strategically aligned, professionally polished, utterly fucking boring people who seem to have been manufactured in the same management consultancy factory.

People who agree with everything.

People who never challenge anything.

People who spend their entire careers perfecting the art of saying absolutely nothing while sounding incredibly important.

No.

I'd want characters.

People with ideas.

People with opinions.

People who are curious about the world.

People who challenge assumptions.

People who make other people think.

People who are funny.

People who are creative.

People who have something genuinely interesting to contribute.

And I wouldn't care whether they were introverted, extroverted, quiet, loud, unconventional or slightly eccentric.

I'd care whether they were good at what they did and whether they treated other people properly.

I don't want a department full of Kevins.

I want people who occasionally tell me I'm talking bollocks.

Especially when I am.

Because if I'm running a company and every single person agrees with everything I say, one of two things is happening.

Either I'm the greatest business leader in human history.

Or I've accidentally employed a collection of spineless fucking sycophants.

And I think we all know which is more likely.

I'd Treat Employees Like Adults

This might be my most controversial policy.

I'd treat grown adults like grown fucking adults.

Imagine that.

People who are old enough to have mortgages, children, marriages, responsibilities and complicated lives would be trusted to organise their own working day.

I wouldn't need to know whether somebody started at 8:03 or 8:17.

I wouldn't need a daily explanation of every task they'd completed.

I wouldn't need to monitor whether their Teams status was green.

And I certainly wouldn't assume that somebody sitting at a desk for nine hours was automatically more productive than somebody who completed the same work in six.

I'd establish clear expectations.

Agree objectives.

Provide the resources.

And trust people to deliver.

If they needed help, they'd ask.

If they were struggling, we'd discuss it.

If they were doing excellent work, I'd recognise it.

And if they were consistently failing to deliver, we'd address that too.

Because treating people like adults doesn't mean abandoning accountability.

It means not treating every employee like a fucking naughty schoolchild who needs supervising in case they sneak off to eat a biscuit.

And if somebody wanted to finish early to collect their children, attend an appointment or simply enjoy their life?

As long as the work was covered and commitments were met, why would I give a fuck?

I'm employing people to produce valuable work.

I'm not purchasing their physical presence as office furniture.

I'd Pay People Properly

Here's another revolutionary concept.

If I wanted talented people to work for me, I'd pay them properly.

Not with reward points.

Not with appreciation badges.

Not with a £15 voucher.

Not with a certificate announcing that they've demonstrated outstanding commitment to the company's values.

Money.

Actual fucking money.

The stuff people use to pay their mortgages, buy food and support their families.

I'd want salaries to be fair, competitive and transparent enough that people understood how decisions were made.

And if somebody took on substantially more responsibility, I'd have an honest conversation about compensation.

I wouldn't spend six months asking them to operate at the next level while dangling a possible promotion somewhere in the distant future.

And I certainly wouldn't expect people to routinely work additional hours for free.

If their contract said 37.5 hours, that would be the arrangement.

Occasional emergencies?

Of course.

Reasonable flexibility?

Absolutely.

But if the company consistently needed people to work fifty hours to complete forty hours of contracted work, that would be a management problem.

Not an employee commitment problem.

And if somebody suggested that people who wanted to progress should demonstrate dedication by donating their evenings?

I'd ask whether they'd be equally happy for the company to demonstrate dedication by paying employees an extra £10,000 for no additional work.

Funny how quickly that particular philosophy collapses when you reverse the fucking transaction.

I'd Actually Train New Employees

When somebody joined my company, they'd have a laptop.

On day one.

Not week three.

Not month two.

Not whenever somebody in IT finally remembers to approve a purchase order.

Day. Fucking. One.

They'd have access to the systems they needed.

They'd know what their job involved.

They'd have a structured induction.

They'd meet the relevant people.

And they'd receive proper training.

Not a collection of mandatory videos about corporate values followed by six months of being told to ask Colin.

And the person responsible for supporting them would actually want to do it.

I'd select mentors who were competent, approachable and interested in helping others develop.

Not somebody who'd worked at the company since 1997 and regarded every question as a personal fucking insult.

And I'd make sure managers understood that inexperienced employees need guidance.

If a twenty-two-year-old graduate joins a company and doesn't know how the organisation works, that's not evidence of generational incompetence.

That's evidence that they're twenty-two and have just joined the fucking company.

Teach them.

Support them.

Challenge them.

Give them meaningful work.

And let them develop.

Of course, I'd expect effort in return.

I wouldn't tolerate somebody demanding a promotion after three weeks because they've successfully completed the introductory training.

But I'd recognise that developing talented people is an investment.

And if we did it properly, perhaps they'd actually want to stay.

I'd Promote People Who Can Actually Lead

This one would probably eliminate half the middle management population.

Being brilliant at writing software doesn't automatically make somebody brilliant at managing people.

Being excellent with spreadsheets doesn't qualify somebody to lead a department.

And being employed for twenty years doesn't mean you're entitled to a management position.

I'd promote people based on their ability to perform the role.

If the role involved managing people, they'd need to demonstrate that they could manage people.

Communicate.

Listen.

Make decisions.

Resolve problems.

Develop talent.

Take responsibility.

And occasionally have a difficult conversation without hiding behind HR.

I'd also create proper progression for technical specialists who didn't want to become managers.

Because forcing excellent engineers into management simply to increase their salaries is a spectacularly stupid way to lose a good engineer and gain a terrible manager.

And I wouldn't employ a Head of IT who openly announced that he didn't like HR or recruitment.

Because that's a fairly significant part of leading an IT department.

If you don't want to recruit, develop or manage people, perhaps you shouldn't be in charge of a department full of fucking people.

It's rather like appointing somebody Head of Catering who announces on their first day that they find food irritating.

I'd Make Managers Accountable

Managers wouldn't exist simply to attend meetings, produce reports and ask employees for updates.

They'd be responsible for making their teams successful.

That means planning workloads.

Removing obstacles.

Providing support.

Making decisions.

Managing resources.

And taking responsibility when things go wrong.

If somebody resigned, I wouldn't automatically dump their responsibilities onto the remaining employees and call it a development opportunity.

I'd assess the workload.

Decide what genuinely needed doing.

Recruit a replacement where necessary.

And have honest conversations about priorities.

Because if somebody leaves and the company still expects the same amount of work to be completed, something has to change.

You either replace the person.

Reduce the workload.

Increase capacity elsewhere.

Or accept that delivery will be affected.

Those are the options.

You don't simply announce that everyone needs to work smarter and hope the laws of mathematics decide to fuck off.

And if a manager repeatedly lost good employees?

I'd want to know why.

Not because I believe every resignation is management's fault.

People leave for all sorts of reasons.

But if the same manager keeps losing talented people, receiving poor feedback and struggling to maintain a functioning team, perhaps we should stop blaming the workforce and start examining the person in charge.

I'd Have Fewer Fucking Meetings

Meetings would have to justify their existence.

Not every conversation needs twelve attendees.

Not every update requires a presentation.

Not every minor issue needs a working group.

And not every Monday needs to begin with forty-five minutes of people explaining what they did on Friday.

If a meeting could be replaced by a useful email, we'd send the email.

If a decision could be made by two people, we wouldn't invite fourteen.

And if somebody organised a meeting without a clear purpose, I'd expect them to explain why everybody's time was being consumed.

Because meetings cost money.

Real money.

Ten people in a one-hour meeting represents ten hours of paid time.

And if the meeting produces no decision, no useful information and no meaningful outcome, we've essentially paid ten people to sit around listening to Kevin describe his weekend.

I'd also ban compulsory Lunch & Learns.

If employees want to attend a learning session, brilliant.

Give them time during the working day.

But I wouldn't expect people to surrender their unpaid lunch break to listen to a presentation about stakeholder engagement while eating a sandwich over their keyboard.

And if somebody wanted to spend their lunch hour sitting in a park doing absolutely fuck all?

Good.

Enjoy it.

I'd Stop the Corporate Bullshit

There would be no requirement to describe every ordinary activity as a transformational journey.

No endless references to strategic alignment.

No compulsory declarations of passion.

No expectation that employees publicly celebrate the organisation on LinkedIn.

No Great Place to Work Champions.

No ridiculous employee appreciation schemes designed to distract people from inadequate salaries.

And no company-wide emails celebrating the successful completion of a fucking workshop.

If we achieved something important, we'd celebrate it.

If somebody did exceptional work, we'd recognise it.

But I wouldn't manufacture enthusiasm.

I wouldn't ask employees to pretend that attending a conference had fundamentally altered their understanding of the universe.

And I wouldn't expect them to describe a redundancy as an exciting new chapter.

I'd want people to be genuine.

If they were happy, brilliant.

If they were frustrated, I'd want to know why.

And if they thought a management decision was stupid, I'd want them to feel comfortable saying so.

Preferably before we spent £300,000 implementing it.

I'd Make the Workplace Fun

Now, here's something I think modern corporate culture has completely misunderstood.

Work doesn't have to be fucking miserable.

People spend an enormous proportion of their lives working.

Why shouldn't they enjoy it?

Why shouldn't they laugh?

Why shouldn't they look forward to seeing their colleagues?

Why shouldn't they find the work interesting, challenging and satisfying?

I'd want a workplace with humour.

Personality.

Energy.

Creativity.

People who genuinely enjoy collaborating.

People who can have a laugh without worrying that somebody from HR is going to produce a seventeen-page policy on appropriate workplace amusement.

But I wouldn't confuse fun with forced participation.

I wouldn't organise compulsory team-building days involving spaghetti towers and personality colours.

I wouldn't drag people into London for an evening event and expect them to spend three hours travelling home because somebody in management thinks socialising is mandatory.

And I wouldn't assume that everyone wants to go to the pub.

Some people would love that.

Others would rather go home.

Both are fine.

Because genuine fun isn't something you can schedule into a calendar invitation titled Mandatory Engagement Experience.

It happens when people enjoy the environment they're working in.

When they trust each other.

When they feel comfortable.

When they can be themselves.

And when the company isn't constantly treating them like fucking idiots.

I'd want people laughing because something was genuinely funny.

Not because Martin has made another joke about the weather and everybody's worried about their performance review.

I'd Make the Actual Jobs Interesting

Free coffee doesn't make a boring job interesting.

Neither does a pool table.

Neither does a colourful office.

Neither does an inspirational quote painted on the wall.

I'd want people doing work that challenged them.

Work where they could develop skills.

Solve problems.

Create things.

Improve systems.

Make decisions.

And see the results of their efforts.

I'd give people autonomy.

I'd encourage experimentation.

I'd welcome sensible ideas from anybody, regardless of their position.

And I wouldn't automatically dismiss a suggestion because it came from somebody with a junior job title.

Sometimes the person closest to the work understands the problem better than the person responsible for producing the strategic presentation about it.

Shocking, I know.

And if somebody had a better way of doing something, I'd want to hear it.

Even if it contradicted my own opinion.

Especially then.

Because I wouldn't want a company where the most senior person automatically wins every argument.

I'd want the best idea to win.

I'd Tell Customers the Truth

Customers would be important.

Of course they would.

Without customers, there's no business.

But I wouldn't operate under the ridiculous assumption that the customer is always right.

Sometimes customers are wrong.

Sometimes they're unreasonable.

Sometimes they don't understand the technical implications of what they're requesting.

And sometimes they're demanding something that simply isn't possible.

I'd expect my employees to treat customers respectfully and professionally.

But I'd also support them when they needed to say no.

I wouldn't allow salespeople to promise impossible deadlines and then expect delivery teams to sacrifice their evenings making those promises appear credible.

I wouldn't let account managers give away additional work simply because they were frightened of an uncomfortable conversation.

And I wouldn't allow customers to abuse employees.

Because having a commercial relationship with somebody doesn't mean they've purchased the right to behave like a fucking prick.

I'd want honest customer relationships built on trust, competence and realistic expectations.

Not unconditional surrender.

I'd Deal With Incompetence Properly

This is important.

Creating a positive workplace doesn't mean tolerating poor performance indefinitely.

Quite the opposite.

Nothing destroys a good team faster than allowing incompetent people to repeatedly make mistakes while everybody else picks up the pieces.

If somebody wasn't performing, I'd want to understand why.

Do they need training?

Are expectations unclear?

Are they overloaded?

Are they in the wrong role?

Or are they simply not doing the job properly?

Then we'd address it.

Fairly.

Directly.

Without turning one person's failure into a compulsory training programme for everybody else.

If an architect implemented an integration without following the correct change process, I'd investigate that specific incident.

I'd establish what happened.

I'd assess the risk.

And I'd ensure the appropriate action was taken.

I wouldn't immediately question whether every other employee in the organisation was also ignoring the rules.

Because that would be fucking stupid.

And I wouldn't protect somebody from accountability simply because they had an impressive job title.

The rules would apply to everyone.

Junior employees.

Senior consultants.

Architects.

Managers.

Directors.

And me.

Especially me.

Because if the person running the company isn't accountable, why the fuck should anybody else be?

I'd Actually Listen to Employees

I wouldn't need an annual survey to discover whether the workforce was miserable.

I'd be talking to people throughout the year.

Not through seventeen layers of management.

Not exclusively through carefully filtered reports.

I'd want to understand what was happening in the business.

What was working.

What wasn't.

What people were frustrated about.

What ideas they had.

And what they thought we could do better.

And when somebody raised a legitimate problem, I'd want us to actually do something about it.

Not establish an employee engagement committee.

Not organise a listening workshop.

Not create a colourful infographic explaining that we've heard their concerns.

I'd want action.

If people were underpaid, we'd review salaries.

If workloads were unreasonable, we'd address capacity.

If managers were ineffective, we'd deal with management.

And if employees repeatedly complained about the same problem, I wouldn't ask them to explain it again in another fucking survey.

I'd assume that perhaps, just perhaps, they were telling the truth.

I'd Want People to Stay

This would be one of my biggest measures of success.

Not whether employees described the company as a family.

Not whether we won a Great Place to Work award.

Not whether our engagement survey produced a colourful collection of positive percentages.

I'd want talented people to choose to stay.

Because they enjoyed the work.

Because they respected their colleagues.

Because they trusted the leadership.

Because they were paid fairly.

Because they had opportunities to develop.

And because they felt the company genuinely valued what they contributed.

Of course, people would still leave.

That's normal.

People change careers.

Move house.

Find different opportunities.

Want new challenges.

And I'd wish them well.

But I wouldn't want people leaving because they'd become exhausted by incompetent management, ridiculous bureaucracy, poor pay and endless corporate bullshit.

And if somebody did leave for those reasons, I'd want to learn from it.

Not send them a survey, ignore the answers and then post something on LinkedIn about their incredible journey.

I Wouldn't Pretend Running a Company Was Easy

Now, let's be realistic.

Running a business involves difficult decisions.

Budgets matter.

Customers matter.

Profitability matters.

Not every employee can have everything they want.

Not every idea is affordable.

Not every salary request can be approved.

And sometimes, despite everyone's best efforts, things go wrong.

I'd have to make decisions that people didn't like.

I'd make mistakes.

I'd occasionally get things wrong.

And I'd probably discover that some problems are considerably more complicated from the other side of the desk.

Fine.

That's leadership.

But I wouldn't use complexity as an excuse for dishonesty, incompetence or treating people badly.

I'd explain decisions.

I'd be transparent where possible.

I'd acknowledge mistakes.

And I'd expect the same standards from myself that I expected from everybody else.

Because being the owner of a company shouldn't mean becoming the most important person in the building.

It should mean accepting the greatest responsibility for making the place work.

The Company I'd Want to Build

So what would my company actually look like?

It wouldn't necessarily have the fanciest offices.

It wouldn't have the most impressive corporate mission statement.

It wouldn't employ an army of consultants to explain what its values should be.

And it certainly wouldn't need a Great Place to Work Champion wandering around trying to convince everybody how fucking wonderful things were.

It would have talented people.

Interesting people.

People with ideas.

People with personality.

People who could challenge each other, learn from each other and occasionally tell each other to stop talking bollocks.

It would have managers who could actually manage.

Leaders who listened.

Employees who were trusted.

Customers who were treated honestly.

And a culture where people could work hard, do something worthwhile, have a laugh and then go home without feeling guilty.

I'd want people to arrive on Monday without experiencing that familiar sinking feeling of impending corporate misery.

I'd want them to feel proud of what they were building.

I'd want them to enjoy working with the people around them.

And I'd want them to know that their contribution mattered.

Not because I'd sent them an appreciation badge.

Not because I'd organised a compulsory wellbeing workshop.

But because the way the company operated demonstrated it.

Every fucking day.

And Finally, Kevin...

Of course, eventually somebody like Kevin would apply.

Kevin would arrive for his interview wearing a beautifully pressed shirt and carrying a leather folder.

He'd have researched the company.

He'd memorised the values.

He'd prepared seventeen examples of stakeholder collaboration.

And he'd describe himself as a passionate, results-driven thought leader with a proven track record of delivering transformative outcomes.

I'd ask him a simple question.

"Kevin, tell me about something you've done that you're genuinely proud of."

He'd smile.

"Well, I'm particularly proud of the strategic alignment initiative I facilitated across multiple stakeholder groups."

"Right. What did you actually achieve?"

"We established a collaborative framework for driving operational excellence."

"Okay. What changed?"

"We created a shared understanding of our transformation priorities."

"Kevin. What the fuck did you actually do?"

Silence.

For the first time in his professional career, Kevin would be completely lost for words.

I'd thank him for coming.

Wish him well.

And show him the door.

Not because he was necessarily a bad person.

But because I'd have absolutely no interest in employing somebody whose greatest professional skill was making nothing sound important.

Then I'd interview somebody else.

Someone who'd built something.

Solved something.

Improved something.

Helped somebody.

Someone with genuine enthusiasm, practical intelligence and an interesting perspective.

Someone who didn't need to hide behind corporate jargon.

Someone who could look me in the eye and say:

"Actually, I think there's a much better way of doing that."

And I'd listen.

Because that's the kind of person I'd want in my company.

Not somebody who agreed with me.

Somebody who made me better.

And if we got enough of those people together, treated them properly, paid them fairly and gave them something worthwhile to do?

Perhaps we'd build something genuinely special.

Not a company that needed to tell everybody how wonderful it was.

A company where people actually wanted to work.

And if somebody from Great Place to Work eventually contacted me asking whether we'd like to participate in their annual certification programme, I'd politely decline.

"Thank you, but we're not interested."

"May I ask why?"

"Because I'd rather spend the money on my employees."

And then I'd hang up.

No fucking vouchers.

No inspirational LinkedIn posts.

No compulsory away days.

No self-important architects who can't spell.

No managers with the emotional intelligence of a garden vegetable.

No corporate arse-kissing competition.

Just good people, doing good work, enjoying themselves and getting paid properly.

And if that sounds like some radical, impossible vision of modern employment, perhaps that tells us everything we need to know about the absolute fucking state of corporate Britain.

#A Better Way