A Better Way

Internal Promotions: Why Pay Your Own Staff More When You Can Pay a Stranger Twice as Much?

There are few things in corporate life more baffling than the recruitment process.

Actually, that's not entirely fair.

Recruitment itself is perfectly reasonable.

Companies need people. People need jobs. Occasionally, somebody leaves and another human being has to be found to replace them.

A fairly straightforward arrangement.

But somewhere along the line, corporate management has developed a fascinating philosophy.

Why promote somebody who already works here when we could spend considerably more money recruiting somebody who doesn't?

It's an extraordinary approach.

And one that appears to have been developed by people who shouldn't be trusted to manage the petty cash at a village fête.

An Exciting Opportunity

Imagine a perfectly ordinary company.

Let's call it Corporate Solutions International.

A senior manager has left.

There's now a vacancy.

The company needs somebody who understands the business, can manage a team, deal with customers, make decisions and deliver results.

Fortunately, there's an employee called David.

David has worked for the company for seven years.

He knows the customers.

He knows the systems.

He knows the processes.

He knows which processes are completely fucking pointless.

He knows which departments are helpful, which managers are difficult and which senior executives require a PowerPoint presentation before they'll approve the purchase of a stapler.

David has already been covering half the responsibilities of the vacant position for the last eighteen months.

His colleagues respect him.

His customers trust him.

And his manager has repeatedly described him as an invaluable member of the team.

Wonderful.

Problem solved.

Promote David.

Give him a reasonable pay rise.

Everybody wins.

Except, apparently, that's not how corporate management works.

The Internal Candidate

David expresses an interest in the position.

His manager is delighted.

"Great to see you taking ownership of your career, mate."

Of course.

Ownership.

That wonderful corporate concept whereby the employee assumes responsibility for everything while management retains the authority to approve absolutely fuck all.

David asks whether he might be considered for promotion.

His manager looks thoughtful.

"Well, it's quite a significant step up."

Is it?

Because I've been doing most of the job for eighteen months.

"Yes, but we'd need somebody who can hit the ground running."

Right.

Somebody who already understands the business?

"Exactly."

Somebody who knows the customers?

"Absolutely."

Somebody familiar with the systems and processes?

"Very important."

Somebody who's already performing many of the responsibilities?

"Definitely."

Excellent.

So you'll consider me?

"Well, we'd really like to see what talent is available externally."

What?

The Search for Fresh Talent

Apparently, the organisation wants to bring in fresh thinking.

New perspectives.

External experience.

Someone who can challenge the status quo.

Which sounds wonderful.

Except David has been challenging the status quo for the last three years.

And every time he does, somebody tells him to follow the fucking process.

But external candidates are different.

They bring fresh perspectives.

When David suggests changing something, he's being negative.

When an external consultant suggests exactly the same thing, he's demonstrating strategic insight.

When David questions an inefficient process, he's being resistant to established ways of working.

When somebody from another company questions it, they're bringing valuable industry experience.

It's remarkable.

Apparently, an idea becomes more valuable the further away from the organisation it originated.

Perhaps David should start submitting his suggestions from a different email address.

Or put on a suit, book a meeting room and introduce himself as an independent transformation specialist.

That'll be £1,200 a day, please.

The Recruitment Agency

The company now contacts a recruitment agency.

Naturally.

Because although the organisation employs hundreds of people, has an entire HR department and possesses a database containing the professional history of every employee, it apparently needs to pay somebody else to find a manager.

The recruiter is delighted.

There's a vacancy.

There's a budget.

There's a commission.

And there's absolutely no reason to mention that a perfectly capable internal candidate is already sitting twelve feet from the hiring manager.

The recruiter begins searching LinkedIn.

Within forty-eight hours, they've identified several exciting candidates.

One has worked for a competitor.

Another has recently completed a transformation programme.

A third has described himself as a visionary leader with a proven track record of delivering strategic outcomes.

Nobody knows what he's actually done.

But he has an impressive LinkedIn banner.

The agency presents its shortlist.

"These are some really strong candidates."

Of course they are.

The agency is being paid to find them.

The Interview

After several weeks, the company interviews a candidate called Richard.

Richard has an excellent CV.

He has worked for four organisations in six years.

At each one, he has apparently transformed something.

He has transformed operational efficiency.

Transformed customer engagement.

Transformed organisational capability.

And, at one particularly unfortunate company, transformed the entire leadership structure.

Nobody asks why he keeps leaving shortly after these transformations.

Richard arrives for the interview wearing an expensive suit and carrying a leather notebook.

He speaks confidently.

He uses phrases such as strategic alignment, commercial maturity and operational excellence.

He explains that he's passionate about driving meaningful change.

The interview panel is captivated.

"How would you approach your first ninety days?"

Richard smiles.

"Well, initially, I'd want to understand the organisation, engage with key stakeholders, assess the existing operating model and identify opportunities for improvement."

Brilliant.

So you'd spend three months learning how the company works?

"Exactly."

The panel nods approvingly.

Outstanding answer.

David, meanwhile, already knows how the company works.

But apparently, that's a disadvantage.

The Salary Negotiation

Eventually, Richard is offered the job.

The salary is £85,000.

David currently earns £55,000.

He'd happily have accepted £65,000.

But when David previously discussed a promotion, management explained that a £10,000 increase would be difficult to justify.

Budget constraints.

Internal pay structures.

Salary banding.

Remuneration governance.

All very complicated.

Fortunately, none of these obstacles appears to apply to Richard.

Richard is an external candidate.

And external candidates have market value.

Internal employees, apparently, have whatever salary they were given several years ago, plus an annual increase that might just about cover the rising cost of a packet of biscuits.

It's a fascinating economic principle.

The same skills are worth more money when they're attached to somebody the company has never met.

But the expense doesn't end there.

Oh no.

There's the recruitment agency fee.

Let's say twenty per cent.

That's another £17,000.

So the company has now committed to an £85,000 salary and paid £17,000 to find someone who doesn't know where the toilets are.

Meanwhile, David is still sitting at his desk.

Doing the job.

For £55,000.

And management is congratulating itself on securing an exceptional external appointment.

The Onboarding Process

Richard starts on Monday.

There's a welcome email.

A company announcement.

A photograph.

A LinkedIn post.

"We're delighted to welcome Richard to the team. He brings a wealth of experience and will play a pivotal role in driving our strategic ambitions."

Wonderful.

Richard spends his first week completing mandatory training.

His second week waiting for system access.

His third week attending introductory meetings.

By week four, he's beginning to understand the organisational structure.

Unfortunately, the organisational structure is about to change.

There's a restructure.

Naturally.

Richard now needs somebody to explain the business.

The customers.

The systems.

The processes.

The reporting arrangements.

The history of the projects.

The reasons certain decisions were made.

And who does management ask to help?

David.

Of course they fucking do.

"David, could you spend some time getting Richard up to speed?"

Absolutely.

Why wouldn't I?

I've only spent seven years developing the knowledge you decided wasn't sufficient to qualify me for the job.

Now I get to spend three months teaching it to the person you've paid £30,000 more to do it.

Fantastic.

Perhaps I could also polish his shoes.

The First Ninety Days

Richard is settling in nicely.

He attends meetings.

He asks questions.

He takes notes.

He occasionally says something about strategic priorities.

Everyone is impressed.

"Really good to have some fresh thinking in the team."

Richard has identified several opportunities for improvement.

For example, he believes the reporting process could be simplified.

Interesting.

David suggested that two years ago.

Richard also thinks the company should review its approval procedures.

Extraordinary.

David raised that eighteen months ago.

And Richard has proposed reducing the number of unnecessary meetings.

Fucking revolutionary.

David has been saying that since approximately 2019.

But this time, the suggestions are taken seriously.

Because Richard has external experience.

The leadership team arranges a workshop.

There's a PowerPoint presentation.

An action plan.

A steering committee.

And eventually, a transformation programme.

David is asked to lead the implementation.

Because he knows how everything works.

The Financial Genius

Now, I'm no economist.

But let's examine the numbers.

The company had an experienced employee earning £55,000.

It could have promoted him to £65,000.

An additional £10,000 per year.

No recruitment agency fee.

Minimal onboarding.

No lengthy familiarisation period.

Existing relationships.

Established knowledge.

A relatively straightforward transition.

Instead, it recruits Richard.

£85,000 salary.

£17,000 agency fee.

Several months learning the business.

Time spent by other employees supporting his onboarding.

And the inevitable disruption while he discovers that the company's internal systems were apparently designed by someone who had recently suffered a serious head injury.

Of course, an external appointment can sometimes be the right decision.

Perhaps the company genuinely needs skills it doesn't possess.

Perhaps nobody internally wants the position.

Perhaps a fresh perspective is essential.

Perfectly reasonable.

But when there's already a capable employee who understands the business and could perform the role with a little support, the financial logic becomes rather difficult to follow.

Apparently, spending more money is acceptable provided it's classified as recruitment rather than rewarding an existing employee.

One is an investment in talent.

The other is a cost increase.

Corporate accounting.

A beautiful thing.

The Retention Problem

Six months later, David resigns.

He's been offered a position elsewhere.

£75,000.

A £20,000 increase.

His manager is shocked.

"Really sorry to hear that, mate. You're such a valued member of the team."

David explains that he wants career progression.

"Have you spoken to us about that?"

Have I spoken to you?

I've submitted promotion evidence.

I've attended development meetings.

I've requested feedback.

I've expressed interest in vacancies.

I've spent three months training the person you recruited instead of me.

What would you like me to do next?

Hire a fucking aircraft and write PROMOTE DAVID across the sky?

Management is disappointed.

They'd really hoped David would stay.

But unfortunately, there's nothing they can do about his salary.

Pay structures.

Budget constraints.

Remuneration governance.

You know the drill.

David leaves.

The company now has another vacancy.

And because David possessed a considerable amount of specialist knowledge, the organisation needs someone experienced to replace him.

Fortunately, there's a recruitment agency that can help.

The Replacement

The recruiter is delighted.

Another vacancy.

Another fee.

Another opportunity to source exceptional talent.

The company advertises the position.

Salary: £75,000 to £85,000.

Experience required: extensive knowledge of the industry, strong stakeholder management, proven delivery capability and the ability to operate independently.

David reads the advert.

Then reads it again.

It's his fucking job.

The job he was doing for £55,000.

The job he asked to be paid £65,000 to continue doing.

The job the company couldn't afford to promote him into.

Now advertised for £85,000.

Plus recruitment costs.

And the leadership team is wondering why employee retention is becoming such a challenge.

Perhaps they should organise a workshop.

The Final Insult

A few months later, Richard attends a leadership meeting.

He's been asked to provide an update on his department.

"Things are progressing well," he explains.

"However, we've experienced some challenges following the departure of a key employee."

The leadership team nods sympathetically.

Richard continues.

"David had a considerable amount of organisational knowledge, and replacing that expertise has proved difficult."

Interesting.

Apparently, David's expertise has become more valuable now that he's no longer employed by the company.

Richard recommends a review of the department's talent strategy.

Excellent idea.

Perhaps they could focus on internal development.

Succession planning.

Employee retention.

Identifying high-potential individuals.

Supporting career progression.

The leadership team is impressed.

"Really good thinking, Richard."

A transformation programme is approved.

A working group is established.

HR develops a new internal mobility framework.

And a consultancy is commissioned to review the company's approach to talent management.

For £120,000.

Meanwhile, David is enjoying his new job.

He's earning £20,000 more.

His former company has spent a small fortune replacing him.

And somewhere in a boardroom, a group of highly paid executives is congratulating itself on its commitment to developing people.

Because in corporate Britain, your experience is apparently worth fuck all while you work here.

But the moment you leave, we'll pay somebody else a fortune to replace it.