A Better Way

Job Interviews: Two Idiots on Teams Pretending They Know What They're Doing

There's something deeply fucking ridiculous about the modern job interview.

Two or three people sit in a meeting for an hour, ask a collection of questions they've probably downloaded from the internet, make an enormous decision about somebody's professional future, and then act completely astonished when the person they hire turns out to be a fucking disaster.

I've seen people hired who leave within months.

I've seen people hired who are subsequently fired.

I've seen candidates who somehow survive three rounds of interviews, a technical assessment and a personality questionnaire, only to arrive on their first day and demonstrate the professional competence of a concussed pigeon.

And every time, management acts surprised.

"Unfortunately, they weren't quite the right fit."

Weren't the right fit?

You interviewed them.

You assessed them.

You checked their references.

You made them explain where they saw themselves in five years.

You probably asked what fucking animal they'd like to be.

And after all that, you've employed somebody who can't operate a spreadsheet without adult supervision.

Perhaps the interview process isn't quite the sophisticated talent-identification system you think it is.

Perhaps it's just a group of people having a chat and pretending they're qualified to predict the future.

Can You Hear Me?

Naturally, before the interview can begin, we must complete the traditional Microsoft Teams opening ceremony.

"Hi Dave, can you hear us?"

"Yes, can you hear me?"

"Yes, we can hear you."

"Great."

"Sorry, I think John's on mute."

"John, you're on mute."

"Can you hear me now?"

"Yes, John."

"Brilliant."

Then somebody's camera freezes.

Somebody else accidentally shares their Outlook inbox.

And the interviewer spends another three minutes apologising because their laptop has decided to install an update.

Fucking marvellous.

We've already wasted seven minutes establishing that three adults possess functioning microphones.

Now we can begin the serious business of determining whether I'm suitable for employment.

So, Dave, Tell Us About Yourself

Here we go.

"So, Dave, tell us a little bit about yourself. What have you been doing for the last five years?"

I'm sorry?

What?

Did you read my fucking CV?

Because I distinctly remember spending several hours preparing a document specifically designed to explain what I've been doing for the last five years.

It's got dates.

Job titles.

Employers.

Responsibilities.

Achievements.

The fucking lot.

And I sent it to you.

In advance.

So you could read it.

Before the interview.

That's generally how this arrangement is supposed to work.

But apparently, you've decided to use the first fifteen minutes of our meeting getting me to read it aloud.

Would you like me to turn the pages for you as well?

Perhaps I could hold it up to the camera.

"Here's a particularly interesting paragraph about my previous role, Martin. Shall I read that one again, or would you prefer to practise sounding out the longer words?"

And let's be clear, there's nothing wrong with asking someone to expand on their experience.

That's the point of an interview.

But asking a candidate to explain their entire employment history from scratch when it's sitting directly in front of you is not insightful questioning.

It's fucking laziness wearing a lanyard.

And Why Are You Interested in This Position?

Because I want a fucking job.

There.

Mystery solved.

I saw a vacancy.

It appeared relevant to my skills.

The salary looked acceptable.

The location was reasonable.

And I thought it might be a better opportunity than whatever I'm currently doing.

So I applied.

What exactly were you expecting?

"Well, Martin, ever since I was a small child, I've dreamed of working for a mid-sized IT services company specialising in enterprise workflow solutions."

"While other children were playing football, I was studying your corporate values."

"At the age of nine, I told my parents that one day, if I worked hard enough, I might become a Senior Platform Consultant in your organisation."

Fuck off.

Nobody dreams of working for your company.

Nobody lies awake at night fantasising about your quarterly revenue targets.

And nobody's childhood ambition was to join a business whose mission statement includes the phrase delivering transformative digital outcomes through collaborative innovation.

I want a job.

You have a job.

I have skills.

You need skills.

Perhaps we could explore whether those things match without pretending I've spent my entire life waiting for this magical fucking moment.

Let Me Tell You a Little Bit About Our Company

Oh, please do.

Because apparently, despite applying for the job, researching the organisation and preparing for the interview, I've somehow neglected to discover what the company actually does.

"We were founded in 1987 and have grown into a leading provider of innovative business solutions."

Yes.

I know.

It's on your website.

"We operate across several international markets."

Yes.

I know.

Also on your website.

"Our core values are integrity, collaboration, innovation and excellence."

Yes.

I fucking know.

There's an entire page devoted to them.

I read it.

Unlike you, who apparently couldn't be bothered to read the three pages I sent you explaining my professional experience.

But please, continue.

Perhaps you could tell me where your head office is located.

Or read me the company mission statement.

Or explain what the logo represents.

I'm particularly interested in the logo.

Does the blue symbolise trust?

Does the green represent sustainability?

Does the abstract orange triangle represent the company's ongoing commitment to wasting everybody's fucking time?

And the really beautiful thing is that interviewers often deliver this information as though they're revealing state secrets.

"We're very passionate about our people."

Really?

That's fascinating.

Because your Glassdoor reviews suggest some of them are considerably less passionate about you.

What Are Your Strengths?

Another classic.

"What would you say are your greatest strengths?"

Well, according to the CV you haven't read, I've spent years developing technical expertise, solving complex problems, managing delivery and working with stakeholders.

But presumably you want me to say something that sounds impressive without appearing arrogant.

So here we go.

"I'm analytical, adaptable, results-driven and passionate about continuous improvement."

There.

Happy?

I've successfully described myself using four phrases that could apply to approximately six million people on LinkedIn.

And now you'll write something down.

Probably "good communicator".

Based on what?

The fact that I can construct a sentence?

Fucking outstanding.

What's Your Greatest Weakness?

Oh, this one can get in the bin.

"What's your greatest weakness?"

My greatest weakness is that I have absolutely no patience for ridiculous fucking interview questions.

But apparently, that's not an acceptable answer.

So I'm expected to invent a charming little flaw that secretly makes me sound wonderful.

"Sometimes I'm too much of a perfectionist."

"I occasionally take on too much responsibility."

"I care too deeply about delivering excellent results."

Oh, fuck off.

We're not interviewing a human being anymore.

We're auditioning for the role of Most Professionally Acceptable Bullshitter.

Nobody says:

"Well, Martin, I'm chronically disorganised, I hate receiving criticism and I once spent three months avoiding a colleague because he ate my yoghurt."

Even if that's the truth.

Because honesty isn't actually what the question rewards.

It rewards the ability to identify the answer the interviewer wants and deliver it without laughing.

Which is a useful skill, admittedly.

Particularly if you're planning a career in senior management.

Where Do You See Yourself in Five Years?

Ideally, alive.

Financially comfortable.

Still reasonably healthy.

And not sitting in another fucking interview answering this question.

But again, that's apparently insufficiently ambitious.

The expected answer is something about professional development, leadership opportunities and contributing to the organisation's long-term success.

Because, naturally, I should already have a detailed five-year career plan involving a company I haven't even joined.

Five years?

I don't know what I'm having for dinner tomorrow.

And you want me to predict my professional circumstances in 2031?

Perhaps I'll be promoted.

Perhaps I'll change careers.

Perhaps the company will be acquired.

Perhaps artificial intelligence will automate half the department.

Perhaps Martin will finally learn how to unmute himself on Teams.

Anything could happen.

But apparently, the correct answer is:

"I see myself continuing to grow within the organisation and taking on increasing responsibility."

Translation:

I'll say whatever makes you happy if it gets us one step closer to discussing the fucking salary.

Tell Me About a Time You Demonstrated Leadership

Ah, competency-based interviewing.

The corporate equivalent of asking someone to perform a rehearsed monologue and then awarding points for remembering the script.

"Can you tell us about a time when you demonstrated leadership in a challenging situation?"

Certainly.

Would you like a genuine example, or would you prefer the beautifully polished version I've prepared specifically for interviews?

Because I can do either.

The genuine version involves a project going spectacularly wrong, several people making questionable decisions, a considerable amount of swearing and me eventually sorting the whole fucking mess out.

But I suspect you'd prefer the STAR format.

Situation.

Task.

Action.

Result.

Wonderful.

Let's transform an actual human experience into a four-part corporate bedtime story.

"During a complex delivery engagement, I identified an opportunity to improve stakeholder alignment..."

What I mean is that nobody knew what the fuck they were doing.

"...so I proactively facilitated a cross-functional discussion..."

I got everyone into a meeting and told them to stop being idiots.

"...which resulted in improved delivery outcomes."

We finally finished the fucking project.

And Martin nods enthusiastically.

"Excellent example."

Of course it is, Martin.

I spent twenty minutes translating reality into the corporate language you apparently need in order to understand it.

The Interviewer Who Thinks He's Interrogating a Murder Suspect

Some interviewers seem to believe the objective is to make candidates uncomfortable.

They sit there with folded arms, looking vaguely disappointed before you've even opened your mouth.

They ask deliberately obscure questions.

They interrupt answers.

They challenge perfectly reasonable statements.

And occasionally they deploy the dreaded silence.

You finish answering.

They stare at you.

You stare back.

Nobody speaks.

Apparently, this is a sophisticated psychological technique designed to see how you respond under pressure.

No, Martin.

You're just being a fucking weirdo.

I'm applying for a job building software.

I'm not being questioned about the disappearance of Lord Lucan.

And if the job genuinely requires me to deal with awkward, hostile people who refuse to communicate properly, perhaps you should put that in the job description.

"Must possess excellent technical skills and the ability to tolerate an emotionally constipated middle manager."

At least then we'd know what we're getting into.

The Technical Interview

Now, technical interviews can be genuinely useful.

If you're hiring somebody to build software, it's reasonable to establish whether they can actually build software.

Revolutionary concept, I know.

But some technical interviews seem designed less to assess competence and more to give the interviewer an opportunity to demonstrate how fucking clever he thinks he is.

"Can you explain the precise behaviour of this obscure function under a very specific edge case?"

"Not off the top of my head, no."

"Interesting."

Interesting?

What's interesting?

That I don't have the entire technical documentation of a software platform permanently tattooed onto my fucking brain?

I've spent years delivering actual projects, solving actual problems and building actual solutions.

But apparently, my suitability for employment depends on whether I can remember a configuration setting I last used in 2021.

And the interviewer looks disappointed.

Because he knows the answer.

Of course he does.

He spent twenty minutes looking it up before the interview.

Congratulations, Martin.

You've won your own fucking quiz.

The Personality Assessment

Sometimes, an interview isn't enough.

No.

The company also needs to establish what sort of personality you have.

So you're sent a questionnaire.

"Do you prefer working independently or collaboratively?"

Depends what I'm doing.

"Are you more analytical or creative?"

Both.

"Do you enjoy working under pressure?"

Not particularly, you fucking lunatic.

"Do you consider yourself a natural leader?"

I consider myself somebody who would quite like to finish this questionnaire before retirement.

And then the results come back.

Apparently, I'm a blue-green personality with strong analytical tendencies and a preference for structured problem-solving.

Fascinating.

What does that mean?

"It means you're thoughtful, logical and detail-oriented."

Excellent.

Could you have established that by reading my CV and having a normal fucking conversation?

Apparently not.

We needed a 64-question personality assessment and a colour-coded PDF.

The Three-Round Interview Process

And then there's the modern obsession with multiple interview stages.

First, a screening call with recruitment.

Then a technical interview.

Then a management interview.

Then a meeting with a senior director.

Then perhaps a presentation.

Then a final cultural-fit conversation.

By the time you've finished, you've met more people than you would at a medium-sized wedding.

And every single one asks some variation of the same fucking questions.

"So, tell me about yourself."

Again?

I told Karen on Monday.

I told Martin on Wednesday.

I told Sandra on Friday.

At this point, I've explained my professional history more times than I've discussed it with my own family.

Perhaps you could all have a fucking conversation with each other.

You know, collaboration.

One of those corporate values you're so passionate about.

And after five interviews, the company announces:

"We've decided to move forward with another candidate."

Fine.

Who did you choose?

"Kevin."

Kevin?

The man who described himself as a visionary thought leader and spent twenty minutes talking about stakeholder synergy?

"Yes. We felt he was an excellent cultural fit."

Of course you fucking did.

The Great Recruitment Mystery

And this brings us back to the original problem.

Despite all these interviews, assessments, competency questions and personality tests, companies still regularly hire people who turn out to be completely unsuitable.

Some leave after three months.

Some are dismissed.

Some spend six months doing very little before somebody notices.

And some become middle managers.

Which is arguably the most dangerous outcome of all.

But what fascinates me is how rarely the people responsible for hiring them seem to question their own judgement.

"We've realised the candidate wasn't quite the right fit."

Really?

What gave it away?

Was it the fact they couldn't do the job?

Or the fact they resigned after eight weeks?

Or perhaps the small matter of them being completely fucking useless?

And what happened during the interview?

Did they suddenly transform into an incompetent idiot after signing the contract?

Did they wake up one morning and forget everything they knew?

Or is it possible that your interview process isn't particularly good at identifying whether somebody can actually perform the role?

Because if you're repeatedly hiring unsuitable people, perhaps the problem isn't always the candidates.

Perhaps the problem is the people making the decisions.

And that's a rather uncomfortable possibility.

Especially when those same people are responsible for deciding who gets promoted.

Perhaps We Could Try Something Radical

What if we treated job interviews as a genuine conversation between two parties trying to establish whether they want to work together?

Imagine that.

The employer reads the CV.

The candidate researches the company.

They discuss the role.

They explore relevant experience.

They ask sensible questions.

They establish whether the candidate has the necessary skills.

And they talk openly about expectations, salary, responsibilities and working conditions.

No ridiculous psychological games.

No pretending that working for a regional IT consultancy has been somebody's lifelong ambition.

No asking people what animal they'd like to be.

And no making somebody explain their entire career history because the interviewer couldn't be bothered to spend ten fucking minutes reading it.

Perhaps we could even acknowledge that the candidate is interviewing the company as well.

Because employment is a two-way arrangement.

You need somebody to do the job.

I need somebody to pay me for doing it.

We're not negotiating a royal marriage.

We're discussing whether I should come and work in your fucking office.

Any Questions for Us?

And finally, after an hour of corporate interrogation, we reach the closing ritual.

"Well, Dave, that brings us to the end of our questions. Is there anything you'd like to ask us?"

Yes, actually.

Quite a lot.

Why did you advertise the salary as "competitive" instead of telling me what it is?

Why has the role been vacant for six months?

Why did the previous employee leave?

Why are there seventeen negative reviews about management on Glassdoor?

Why does your website describe the company as a family?

And why, after spending an hour assessing my suitability for the role, have you demonstrated absolutely no interest in explaining what it's actually like to work here?

But apparently, I'm supposed to ask something suitably enthusiastic.

"What would success look like in the first six months?"

Martin smiles.

"Excellent question."

Thank you, Martin.

I found it on Google.

Just like you found yours.

And then comes the final question.

"Why should we hire you?"

Well, Martin, let's review.

You advertised a job.

I applied.

You received my CV.

You invited me to an interview.

I've spent the last hour explaining my experience, answering your questions and demonstrating my suitability.

And now, apparently, you want me to summarise the entire fucking exercise because you haven't been paying attention.

So here's my answer.

Because I can do the job, you need somebody to do the job, and unlike you, I actually bothered to prepare for this fucking meeting.

"Thank you, Dave. We'll be in touch."

Lovely.

And three weeks later, the email arrives.

"After careful consideration, we've decided to proceed with a candidate whose experience more closely aligns with our requirements."

Fair enough.

Six months later, I see the same job advertised again.

Oh, for fuck's sake.

#Corporate Fuckery