A Better Way

Middle Management: Proof That Being Good at Excel Doesn't Mean You're Good at People

There's a particular species of human being found in corporate offices across the country.

Usually male. Often middle-aged. Frequently balding. Occasionally sweating through a shirt that hasn't quite forgiven him for the previous Christmas buffet.

He has the personality of a fucking brick, the emotional intelligence of a parking meter and the managerial instincts of a confused garden vegetable.

He is the Middle Manager.

And somehow, despite possessing absolutely none of the qualities you'd normally associate with leading other human beings, he's been given responsibility for twelve of them.

Wonderful.

Now, before anyone gets upset, I'm not suggesting that all middle managers are overweight, balding, socially awkward men with the interpersonal skills of a damp tea towel.

Some have excellent hair.

The point is that somewhere along the corporate evolutionary process, we've decided that being exceptionally good at a technical task automatically qualifies someone to manage people.

Dave was brilliant at building software.

Dave could write code, fix defects and explain complex technical architecture without consulting Google.

So naturally, the company promoted Dave into a position where he no longer builds software and instead has to manage twelve people, resolve conflicts, develop careers, conduct performance reviews and occasionally recognise that another human being is experiencing an emotion.

Dave is fucking hopeless at all of it.

But congratulations, Dave.

You're a manager now.

The Great Corporate Promotion System

Imagine you're running a hospital.

You've got an absolutely brilliant surgeon. World-class. Can perform a complicated operation while simultaneously explaining the offside rule.

So you decide to promote him.

"Congratulations, Doctor. You're now Head of Hospital Operations."

"Fantastic. What does that involve?"

"Managing 400 employees, handling budgets, resolving staffing disputes, overseeing recruitment and developing organisational strategy."

"But I'm a surgeon."

"Yes, and a very good one. That's why we've promoted you."

"But I don't know anything about managing a hospital."

"Don't worry. We'll send you on a two-day leadership course."

And that's corporate management.

Except instead of a surgeon, it's a bloke called Martin who knows how to build a spreadsheet.

Martin's spreadsheet is fucking magnificent.

It's got pivot tables, macros, conditional formatting and a dashboard that changes colour depending on whether somebody has updated their timesheet.

Martin is a wizard.

A genuine Excel wizard.

Unfortunately, Martin also has the conversational ability of a deceased badger.

He can't handle disagreement, doesn't understand motivation, avoids difficult conversations and believes employee development means sending somebody a link to an online training course.

But look at those fucking pivot tables.

Promote him immediately.

Technical Ability Is Not Management Ability

This shouldn't be controversial.

Being good at building software doesn't mean you're good at managing software developers.

Being good at accounting doesn't mean you're good at managing accountants.

Being good at sales doesn't automatically mean you're good at leading a sales team.

And being able to produce a beautiful spreadsheet doesn't mean you should be trusted with the emotional wellbeing and professional development of twelve other human beings.

These are completely different skills.

But corporations seem determined to pretend otherwise.

The result is an entire layer of management populated by people who were promoted because they were excellent at something they no longer do.

And the really tragic part is that some of them were perfectly happy doing it.

Dave loved writing code.

He was good at writing code.

He was respected for writing code.

Now Dave spends his days approving annual leave, attending resource allocation meetings and trying to understand why Sarah is upset that he described her promotion request as "not currently aligned with business priorities".

Dave doesn't want to manage people.

The people don't want Dave managing them.

But Dave's got a £7,000 pay rise and a new title, so everybody's pretending it's a fucking success.

The Emotional Intelligence of a House Brick

The problem becomes particularly obvious when an employee needs something that can't be resolved with a spreadsheet.

Perhaps they're struggling with their workload.

Perhaps they're unhappy with their career progression.

Perhaps they're dealing with a difficult colleague.

Perhaps they're simply having a bad time and need somebody to listen.

A good manager understands that human beings aren't identical pieces of equipment.

A bad manager treats every conversation as an inconvenient interruption to something more important.

"Can I have a quick word? I'm struggling with the workload."

"Have you updated the resource tracker?"

"Yes, but I'm feeling completely overwhelmed."

"Have you raised a risk?"

"Martin, I'm telling you I'm struggling."

"Okay. Can you put that in an email?"

For fuck's sake.

The employee isn't reporting a broken printer.

They're asking for help.

And Martin's trying to raise a fucking support ticket.

I sometimes wonder whether certain managers have ever experienced a meaningful conversation outside the workplace.

Not because they're single, divorced or socially awkward. None of those things tells you whether someone can manage people.

But because watching some of them attempt empathy is like watching a vending machine try to console a grieving widow.

"I'm sorry for your loss. Please select an option from the menu."

The Manager Who Didn't Like HR or Recruitment

Now, I've encountered some extraordinary examples of managerial incompetence over the years.

But one particular incident deserves its own fucking museum.

I was once sitting in a meeting when a senior IT manager openly announced that he didn't like HR or recruitment.

Let that sink in.

A man responsible for running an IT department.

A man whose responsibilities involved managing people, building teams, recruiting talent, developing staff and ensuring the department had the skills it needed.

Didn't like HR.

Or recruitment.

He actually said it.

Out loud.

In a meeting.

And apparently thought this was a perfectly reasonable thing to announce.

I'm sorry, WHAT?

You're the fucking head of an IT department.

Recruitment isn't some obscure optional hobby you've been asked to take up on a Wednesday afternoon.

It's part of running a department.

People leave.

People join.

Teams grow.

Skills change.

Vacancies need filling.

Employees need supporting.

And you, the person responsible for the department, have just announced that you don't particularly like dealing with two of the functions most closely connected to managing your workforce.

What the actual fuck?

That's like a head chef announcing he doesn't like cooking.

Or a headteacher declaring that children get on his nerves.

Or a fire chief saying he finds fires a bit stressful and would prefer not to get involved.

Imagine a pilot announcing before take-off:

"Just so everyone's aware, I'm not particularly keen on flying or landing aircraft."

Fucking brilliant.

Would anybody like to get off?

And here's what made it especially insulting.

I spent years working in recruitment.

I understand how difficult it can be to find good people, assess capability, build relationships and make decisions that affect someone's career.

I've also spent years working in IT.

So I understand both sides of that equation.

And here was somebody sitting in a senior leadership position, openly dismissing two areas that are fundamental to the success of his department.

If that isn't a kick in the fucking teeth for people who've actually developed those skills, I don't know what is.

Perhaps he'd have preferred the department to recruit itself.

Maybe the servers could conduct interviews.

The laptops could negotiate salaries.

And the printers could handle employee grievances.

Although, judging by the average office printer, they'd probably spend six months refusing to communicate with anyone.

The extraordinary thing wasn't even that he disliked recruitment.

People are allowed to dislike parts of their jobs.

I don't particularly enjoy every aspect of mine.

The extraordinary thing was that he appeared perfectly comfortable announcing it as though it were somebody else's problem.

You're the leader.

It's your fucking department.

You don't get to enjoy the title, the salary and the authority while treating the responsibilities as an irritating administrative inconvenience.

And if you genuinely have no interest in the people side of leadership, perhaps you should consider a career that doesn't involve leading fucking people.

The One-to-One Meeting

One of the greatest inventions in modern corporate management is the monthly one-to-one.

In theory, it's an opportunity for a manager to understand how an employee is performing, what support they need, what they're hoping to achieve and whether anything is preventing them from doing their best work.

In practice, it frequently resembles a hostage negotiation conducted by two people who would rather be somewhere else.

"How are things going?"

"Fine."

"Good."

Silence.

"Anything you need from me?"

"Well, actually, I'd like to discuss my career progression."

"Okay. Have you completed your development plan?"

"Yes. I sent it to you three weeks ago."

"Right. I'll take a look."

Wonderful.

Thank you, Martin.

We've been having these meetings for eighteen months and you still don't know what I fucking do.

But apparently, you're responsible for my career development.

Perhaps next month we could discuss my favourite colour.

Or whether I prefer tea or coffee.

At least then you'd know something about me.

The Annual Performance Review

And then, once a year, the middle manager is required to perform the terrifying task of evaluating another human being.

Naturally, this is far too complicated to accomplish through observation, regular conversations or an understanding of the employee's actual work.

So the employee is asked to write their own performance review.

Then collect their own feedback.

Then document their own achievements.

Then explain why they deserve a promotion.

And finally, present all this information to the person who's supposedly been managing them for the previous twelve months.

It's fucking magnificent.

Imagine going to a restaurant and being asked to cook your own dinner, serve it to yourself, wash the dishes and then provide the chef with a written explanation of why he deserves a Michelin star.

And after all that, Martin announces:

"I think you're performing really well, but we need to see more evidence of leadership."

More evidence?

I've just done your fucking job for you.

How much more leadership would you like?

Shall I conduct your performance review as well?

The Manager Who Manages Absolutely Nothing

Another fascinating characteristic of bad middle management is the ability to spend an entire working week being incredibly busy while apparently achieving fuck all.

Their calendars are full.

Back-to-back meetings.

Resource reviews.

Capacity planning.

Delivery governance.

Operational updates.

Stakeholder alignment.

They have absolutely no time.

Yet when you need a decision, they're unavailable.

When you need an escalation resolved, they're waiting for another meeting.

When you need support, they're "looking into it".

And when you ask what they've actually accomplished, they produce a PowerPoint presentation showing how busy everyone is.

Thanks, Martin.

I was wondering whether we were busy.

Now that you've spent three hours creating a slide confirming that we're busy, I feel considerably better.

Perhaps next week you could produce a spreadsheet explaining why nobody has time to do any work.

The Peter Principle, With a Fucking Lanyard

There's an established concept called the Peter Principle, which suggests that people in hierarchical organisations can be promoted until they reach a position they're no longer competent to perform.

Corporate life seems determined to turn this into a competitive sport.

A brilliant developer becomes a mediocre team leader.

A mediocre team leader becomes an incompetent department manager.

An incompetent department manager becomes a senior director.

And eventually, the person who was once genuinely excellent at building software is sitting in a boardroom making decisions about hundreds of employees while demonstrating the emotional maturity of a garden slug.

And nobody wants to admit the promotion was a mistake.

Because that would involve accountability.

And accountability is something senior management prefers to discuss in presentations rather than practise.

So instead, the organisation invents another leadership framework.

Another competency matrix.

Another development programme.

Another workshop.

And Martin gets sent on a course called Leading With Empathy.

He returns two days later with a certificate, a branded notebook and precisely the same personality.

"How was the course, Martin?"

"Very informative."

"Learn anything?"

"Yes. Apparently, people appreciate being listened to."

Fucking groundbreaking.

Next week: Water Is Wet.

Management Should Be a Profession, Not a Consolation Prize

Here's the thing.

I don't expect managers to be perfect.

I don't expect them to be endlessly cheerful, charismatic motivational speakers who spend their days hugging employees and telling everyone they're amazing.

And I certainly don't care whether they're bald, overweight, married, single or divorced.

I care whether they can actually fucking manage.

Can they make decisions?

Can they communicate?

Can they recognise talent?

Can they resolve conflict?

Can they develop people?

Can they take responsibility when things go wrong?

Can they have a difficult conversation without hiding behind HR, a spreadsheet or a fucking competency framework?

Because those are the skills that matter.

Not whether they once wrote an exceptional piece of software.

Not whether they've been at the company for fifteen years.

Not whether they're technically brilliant.

And definitely not whether they can produce a PowerPoint presentation with seventeen arrows pointing towards the word STRATEGY.

If somebody wants to become a manager, brilliant.

Train them.

Support them.

Assess whether they have the aptitude.

And if they don't, stop fucking promoting them into positions where their incompetence becomes everybody else's problem.

Create proper technical career paths that reward expertise without forcing people into management.

Let brilliant developers remain brilliant developers.

Let excellent analysts remain excellent analysts.

And let the people who genuinely understand leadership manage the fucking people.

It's not complicated.

Congratulations, Martin. You've Been Promoted.

Of course, none of this will happen.

Because somewhere, right now, a company is preparing to promote its most technically capable employee into a management position.

He's never managed anyone.

He's never recruited anyone.

He's never resolved a workplace dispute.

He's never developed another person's career.

And his last meaningful interaction with HR involved asking why his annual leave balance was incorrect.

But he's fantastic at spreadsheets.

Absolutely fucking outstanding.

The announcement goes out.

"We're delighted to announce Martin's promotion to Head of People and Technology."

Head of People.

Martin.

A man who considers eye contact an unnecessary administrative burden.

His first leadership meeting is scheduled for Monday.

Sandra will explain the importance of employee engagement.

Karen will introduce the new performance management framework.

Kevin will congratulate him on LinkedIn.

And somebody will ask Martin what he's most looking forward to in his new role.

"Well, I'm really excited about the technology side. To be honest, I'm not particularly interested in HR or recruitment."

Of course you're fucking not.

Congratulations, Martin.

You're exactly the sort of manager this company deserves.

And precisely the sort its employees don't.

#Corporate Fuckery