The Business of Business: How We Turned Selling Shit and Making Money Into a Monumental Corporate Wankfest
I have a theory.
And it's one that will probably upset a considerable number of people who describe themselves as strategic thought leaders on LinkedIn.
Business isn't nearly as complicated as the people running businesses would like us to believe.
Now, before some overweight executive in a £900 suit starts choking on his artisan coffee, let me clarify something.
Running a successful business is difficult.
Of course it is.
You need customers. You need money. You need capable people. You need to manage risk, comply with the law, pay your taxes, deliver what you've promised and make enough profit to keep the whole thing going.
None of that is particularly easy.
But the underlying principles are hardly a fucking mystery.
Sell something people want.
Charge enough to make a profit.
Keep your customers reasonably happy.
Don't take on customers who make everyone's life miserable.
Employ people who know what they're doing.
Pay them properly.
Treat them decently.
Have some sensible rules.
Don't behave like a complete cunt.
And perhaps, if you're feeling particularly adventurous, have a bit of fun along the way.
There you go.
A business philosophy.
Eight lines.
No PowerPoint presentation.
No leadership retreat.
No fucking transformation programme.
And absolutely no need to pay somebody £1,500 a day to explain it.
Unfortunately, modern corporate Britain has decided that this approach lacks strategic sophistication.
So we've invented something much better.
An entire industry dedicated to making straightforward things sound incredibly fucking complicated.
Once Upon a Time, There Was a Business
Imagine a small company.
Let's call it Dave's Widgets.
Dave makes widgets.
Good widgets.
Customers like his widgets.
They buy them.
Dave makes a profit.
Everybody's happy.
Business is going well, so Dave employs Sarah to help with orders.
Sarah is competent, reliable and reasonably pleasant.
Dave pays her fairly.
Sarah does a good job.
Eventually, Dave employs another three people.
Then five.
Then ten.
He needs somebody to manage the accounts.
Fair enough.
He needs somebody to organise production.
Perfectly sensible.
He needs someone to deal with customers.
Absolutely.
Before long, Dave has a successful business employing fifty people.
The company makes money.
Customers are satisfied.
Employees are treated reasonably well.
And Dave still knows what the company actually does.
It makes fucking widgets.
Then one day, Dave makes a terrible mistake.
He hires a management consultant.
The Consultant Arrives
The consultant is called Quentin.
Of course he is.
Quentin arrives wearing a tailored suit and carrying a laptop worth more than Dave's first car.
He introduces himself as a business transformation specialist.
Dave explains that the company makes widgets.
Quentin looks concerned.
"Yes, but what's your overarching strategic purpose?"
Dave thinks for a moment.
"Well, we make widgets."
Quentin nods sympathetically.
"Right. But what value proposition are you delivering to the market?"
"Widgets."
"Yes, but what differentiates your customer offering?"
"They're good widgets."
Quentin takes a deep breath.
Clearly, there's a lot of work to do.
He explains that Dave's business has tremendous potential but lacks strategic maturity.
Apparently, the company needs a vision.
A mission.
A set of values.
An operating model.
A transformation roadmap.
And a comprehensive stakeholder engagement strategy.
Dave asks whether any of this will help him sell more widgets.
Quentin smiles.
"Absolutely. It's about creating the foundations for sustainable, scalable growth."
Dave doesn't understand a fucking word of it.
But Quentin seems confident.
And he has an expensive watch.
So Dave agrees.
Six months later, Dave's Widgets has spent £180,000 on consultancy fees.
It now has a mission statement.
Empowering Tomorrow Through Innovative Widget Solutions.
Wonderful.
It still makes exactly the same widgets.
The Mission Statement
Why does every company need a mission statement that sounds as though it was written by a committee of people suffering from a collective head injury?
Whatever happened to saying what you actually do?
"We manufacture quality widgets at competitive prices."
Perfect.
Clear.
Understandable.
But apparently, that's not inspiring enough.
No.
The company must be on a journey.
It must have a purpose.
It must transform lives.
It must create meaningful impact.
It must empower communities.
And it must do all this while delivering sustainable value to stakeholders.
For fuck's sake.
You're selling office furniture.
You're not negotiating world peace.
And there's nothing wrong with selling office furniture.
People need desks.
People need chairs.
If you make decent furniture, deliver it on time and charge a fair price, you're providing something genuinely useful.
Why isn't that enough?
Why must every organisation pretend it's fundamentally changing the course of human civilisation?
A company selling printer cartridges doesn't need to be reimagining the future of human productivity.
It needs to sell printer cartridges.
Preferably ones that fucking work.
The Corporate Values
Next, Quentin explains that Dave's Widgets needs company values.
Apparently, values are essential for creating a strong organisational culture.
Dave thinks about this.
"Well, I'd like everyone to be honest, work together, treat customers properly and do a good job."
Quentin is impressed.
"Excellent starting point, Dave. But we need to elevate the language."
Of course we do.
So honesty becomes Uncompromising Integrity.
Teamwork becomes Collaborative Excellence.
Doing a good job becomes Relentless Commitment to Quality.
And being nice to customers becomes Customer-Centric Empowerment.
Four values.
Each accompanied by a paragraph of inspirational corporate bollocks.
The values are printed on posters.
They're added to the company website.
They're included in employee induction packs.
And there's a compulsory workshop to explain what they mean.
Sarah, who has been treating customers properly for the last seven years without needing a fucking poster, is now required to complete an online assessment demonstrating her commitment to Customer-Centric Empowerment.
She scores 80%.
Apparently, there's room for improvement.
Meanwhile, Quentin has invoiced another £12,000.
The Management Structure
As the business grows, Dave realises he needs managers.
That's reasonable.
Somebody has to coordinate work, make decisions, support employees and ensure things get done.
But Quentin has a better idea.
The company needs a leadership structure.
Not just managers.
Leaders.
Strategic leaders.
Operational leaders.
Transformational leaders.
People leaders.
Dave asks what the difference is.
Quentin explains that managers manage, whereas leaders lead.
Fascinating.
And what do the leaders actually do?
"They provide strategic direction, enable organisational capability and drive business outcomes."
Right.
So they manage?
"Not exactly."
Dave is confused.
But Quentin assures him this is perfectly normal.
Before long, the company has a Head of Operations.
A Head of People.
A Head of Transformation.
A Director of Strategic Development.
A Chief Customer Experience Officer.
And somebody called the Vice President of Organisational Enablement.
Nobody knows what the last person does.
Including the Vice President of Organisational Enablement.
But he earns £140,000.
And has an assistant.
Meanwhile, Sarah is still processing orders.
Except now she has to attend a weekly meeting to explain how many orders she's processed.
Then a monthly meeting to discuss opportunities to improve order processing.
And a quarterly meeting to review the strategic direction of the order-processing function.
She has considerably less time to process actual fucking orders.
But management is delighted.
Visibility has improved.
The Meeting Culture
Meetings are not inherently pointless.
Sometimes people genuinely need to discuss things, make decisions and coordinate work.
That's perfectly sensible.
But somewhere in corporate Britain, meetings stopped being a means of achieving something and became an achievement in themselves.
People now attend meetings to demonstrate that they're involved.
They arrange meetings to establish that they're engaged.
They contribute to meetings to ensure they're visible.
And when nobody can agree on anything, they arrange another meeting.
The company now has a weekly operational review.
A monthly performance review.
A quarterly business review.
A strategic alignment meeting.
A leadership forum.
A resource planning meeting.
A transformation steering committee.
And a monthly meeting to review the effectiveness of the meetings.
I'm not making the last one up as a concept.
Organisations genuinely review meeting effectiveness.
Which is reasonable if the objective is to eliminate unnecessary meetings.
Unfortunately, the review itself can become another permanent fixture in the calendar.
The irony is fucking magnificent.
At Dave's Widgets, the management team spends so much time discussing operational efficiency that the employees responsible for operations are becoming increasingly inefficient.
Sarah points this out.
She's told to raise it at the next operational excellence workshop.
The Language of Business
One of the most extraordinary achievements of modern corporate culture is its ability to make ordinary English sound like a foreign language.
Nobody simply talks anymore.
They engage.
Nobody asks a question.
They seek clarification.
Nobody helps someone.
They provide support through collaborative engagement.
Nobody makes a decision.
They establish alignment.
Nobody fixes a problem.
They implement a targeted remediation initiative.
And nobody says, "I don't know."
They say, "That's something we're currently exploring."
Consider the following sentence.
"We need to improve sales and reduce costs."
Perfectly understandable.
Now listen to the corporate version.
"We need to leverage cross-functional synergies to optimise our commercial proposition while driving operational efficiencies across the wider business ecosystem."
What?
What the actual fuck are you talking about?
It's the same sentence.
Except somebody has taken twelve perfectly ordinary words and replaced them with twenty-three words that make everyone sound as though they're suffering from a particularly aggressive form of LinkedIn poisoning.
And the worst part?
People are rewarded for speaking like this.
An employee who says, "We need to stop wasting money," is being negative.
A senior executive who says, "We need to optimise our cost base through a strategic efficiency programme," is demonstrating commercial leadership.
Same idea.
Different vocabulary.
Considerably different salary.
The Strategic Plan
Every company needs a strategy.
Of course it does.
It needs to understand its market, its customers, its competitors, its costs and where it intends to go.
That's sensible business planning.
But apparently, a strategy isn't a strategy unless it has a name.
And a diagram.
Preferably involving pillars.
Corporate Britain fucking loves pillars.
Three strategic pillars.
Four pillars of growth.
Five pillars of excellence.
Occasionally, a strategic house.
With foundations.
And a roof.
And some sort of overarching purpose floating above it.
Dave's Widgets now has five strategic pillars.
Growth.
Innovation.
People.
Customers.
Operational Excellence.
Groundbreaking.
A company wants to grow, innovate, employ people, serve customers and operate efficiently.
What a remarkable collection of ambitions.
What exactly was the previous strategy?
Lose customers?
Employ nobody?
Make worse widgets?
Apparently, the leadership team spent three months developing these pillars.
They held workshops.
Conducted stakeholder interviews.
Reviewed market trends.
Analysed competitor positioning.
And produced a forty-eight-page strategy document.
At the end of it, Dave asks what the company should actually do differently.
Quentin replies:
"We need to focus on executing against our strategic priorities."
Thanks, Quentin.
That's cleared everything up.
The Employee Experience
Now we arrive at one of my favourite areas of corporate self-importance.
The employee experience.
Apparently, simply employing people, paying them fairly, giving them reasonable working conditions and treating them with respect is no longer sufficient.
No.
Employees need an experience.
An employee journey.
A sense of belonging.
A meaningful connection to the organisational purpose.
Which is lovely.
But most employees aren't particularly complicated.
They want to be paid properly.
They want manageable workloads.
They want competent managers.
They want opportunities to progress.
They want to be treated fairly.
And they want to finish work at a reasonable time without somebody sending them a fucking Teams message at 5:27 pm asking for a quick favour.
But these things are difficult.
Pay rises cost money.
Reducing workloads requires resources.
Improving management means holding managers accountable.
So instead, companies introduce initiatives.
Wellbeing Wednesdays.
Mindfulness Mondays.
Employee Appreciation Week.
Values Champions.
Recognition Points.
Resilience Workshops.
And compulsory Lunch & Learns.
The company now has a Head of Employee Happiness.
Sarah asks for a pay rise.
Unfortunately, there's no budget.
But she can attend a free webinar about managing financial stress.
You couldn't make this shit up.
Actually, you could.
But you'd struggle to make it more ridiculous than some of the things organisations genuinely do.
The Great Transformation
Eventually, Quentin announces that Dave's Widgets needs a transformation programme.
Dave asks why.
The business is profitable.
Customers are happy.
Orders are increasing.
What exactly needs transforming?
Quentin explains that the organisation must remain agile in a rapidly evolving marketplace.
Naturally.
He recommends a comprehensive review of the operating model.
The transformation programme will take eighteen months.
It will require a programme director.
Two project managers.
A change management specialist.
Several business analysts.
And an external advisory partner.
Dave asks what they'll be doing.
"Transforming the business."
Yes, Quentin.
You've mentioned that.
But transforming it into what?
"A more agile, customer-centric and future-ready organisation."
Right.
So what will actually change?
"We'll determine that during the discovery phase."
Fucking brilliant.
We've committed to spending half a million pounds transforming something, but we haven't yet decided what needs transforming.
Still, the programme has a name.
PROJECT HORIZON.
There's a logo.
A newsletter.
A dedicated Teams channel.
And a launch event.
The launch event is held at a hotel.
There's a motivational speaker.
A buffet.
And a presentation explaining why everyone needs to embrace change.
Sarah asks whether the new system will make order processing easier.
Nobody knows.
But everyone agrees that Project Horizon represents an exciting opportunity.
The Cost of All This Bollocks
Here's where the comedy becomes slightly less amusing.
Because all this corporate theatre costs money.
Real money.
Salaries.
Consultancy fees.
Software subscriptions.
Conference facilities.
Travel expenses.
Training programmes.
Internal communications.
And, perhaps most significantly, employee time.
Every hour spent in an unnecessary meeting is an hour not spent doing something else.
That doesn't automatically mean every meeting is wasteful.
Coordination has value.
Planning has value.
Good management has value.
But time has a cost, even when nobody receives a separate invoice for it.
Imagine fifty employees attending a two-hour meeting.
That's one hundred working hours.
If their average employment cost were £40 per hour, the meeting would represent £4,000 of staff time.
Not £4,000 in additional cash expenditure, necessarily.
But £4,000 worth of time that could have been used elsewhere.
Now imagine the meeting achieves absolutely fuck all.
Nobody makes a decision.
Nobody resolves a problem.
Nobody learns anything useful.
And the only outcome is an agreement to arrange another meeting.
Congratulations.
You've just spent £4,000 establishing that you need to spend more money discussing the same thing.
And the people responsible for this masterpiece are probably the same people telling employees that the company needs to become more cost-conscious.
The Problem With Management
Now, here's something that might surprise you.
I don't actually think management is inherently pointless.
Quite the opposite.
Good managers are enormously valuable.
They make decisions.
Remove obstacles.
Support their teams.
Develop people.
Allocate resources.
Deal with problems.
And take responsibility when things go wrong.
A good manager can make an entire department more effective.
The problem is that corporate culture doesn't always reward these behaviours.
Sometimes it rewards something else entirely.
Visibility.
Presentation.
Confidence.
Political awareness.
The ability to speak convincingly about things without necessarily understanding them.
The ability to produce an impressive strategy document.
The ability to chair a meeting.
The ability to say "commercially aligned" without laughing.
And perhaps most importantly, the ability to make relatively ordinary work sound extraordinarily significant.
Someone who quietly solves problems might be considered a dependable employee.
Someone who gives a forty-minute presentation about creating a framework for solving problems might be considered leadership material.
And that's a fucking problem.
Because eventually, organisations can end up with too many people discussing the work and not enough people doing it.
The Corporate Ego
But I think there's something else going on.
Something beyond bureaucracy, bad management and unnecessary complexity.
Corporate self-importance.
The extraordinary belief that everything a company does must be significant.
Every decision is strategic.
Every change is transformational.
Every meeting is collaborative.
Every project is critical.
Every initiative is exciting.
Every employee is on a journey.
And every senior executive is apparently a visionary leader.
Nobody is allowed to simply run a decent business.
That would be far too ordinary.
No.
The organisation must be pioneering the future.
Redefining the industry.
Reimagining possibilities.
Unlocking potential.
Empowering people.
And transforming tomorrow.
All while selling exactly the same fucking product it sold last Tuesday.
And of course, this self-importance spreads.
Employees start describing themselves as passionate thought leaders.
Managers become inspirational change agents.
HR becomes People and Culture.
Customer service becomes Customer Experience.
The IT department becomes Digital Enablement.
And the person responsible for ordering stationery becomes Procurement Transformation Lead.
Everyone sounds incredibly important.
Nobody can explain why the printer hasn't worked since February.
The LinkedIn Effect
Naturally, all this corporate self-importance needs an audience.
And where better to find one than LinkedIn?
The world's largest gathering of people congratulating themselves for having jobs.
Every promotion is a humbling honour.
Every conference is an incredible experience.
Every meeting is an inspiring opportunity.
Every business trip is a privilege.
And every senior executive is delighted, proud, honoured and excited.
Nobody ever posts:
"Spent six hours in meetings today. Achieved absolutely fuck all. Going home."
No.
Instead:
"An incredibly energising day collaborating with some truly inspirational colleagues as we continue our journey towards delivering meaningful outcomes."
What outcomes?
Nobody knows.
But there are photographs.
Usually of people standing in front of a company logo.
Or pointing at a flipchart.
Or shaking hands.
Or sitting around a table looking thoughtful.
Occasionally, Quentin appears.
He's just returned from another international leadership summit.
Apparently, the conversations were invaluable.
The relationships were meaningful.
The opportunities were exciting.
And the experience was truly humbling.
Quentin has now been humbled in seventeen countries.
At considerable expense.
The Customer Has Left the Building
Meanwhile, something rather unfortunate has happened at Dave's Widgets.
Customers are becoming unhappy.
Orders are taking longer.
Problems aren't being resolved.
Prices have increased.
And the quality of the widgets has started to deteriorate.
Dave asks what's going on.
The Head of Customer Experience explains that the company is currently reviewing its end-to-end customer engagement framework.
The Director of Transformation says the organisation is transitioning towards a more scalable operating model.
The Head of Operations explains that several process optimisation initiatives are underway.
And Quentin recommends a strategic review.
Dave asks a simple question.
"Why aren't we making decent widgets anymore?"
Silence.
Nobody knows.
The people who actually make the widgets have been raising concerns for months.
But their concerns were logged as operational improvement opportunities.
Then added to a register.
Then prioritised.
Then deferred.
Then transferred into Project Horizon.
Which is currently awaiting approval from the transformation steering committee.
The employees know what's wrong.
The customers know what's wrong.
Even Dave knows what's wrong.
But management needs another workshop to establish a shared understanding of the problem.
The Revolutionary New Strategy
Eventually, the business begins losing money.
Customers leave.
Employee turnover increases.
Productivity falls.
The leadership team is concerned.
Very concerned.
A crisis meeting is arranged.
Quentin recommends an urgent strategic reset.
Naturally.
The company commissions an external review.
The consultants interview employees.
Speak to customers.
Analyse financial performance.
Review operational processes.
And examine the organisational structure.
After nine months, they present their findings.
The report is 137 pages long.
It contains graphs.
Charts.
Benchmarking data.
A maturity assessment.
And a comprehensive transformation roadmap.
The recommendations are presented to the board.
The room falls silent.
Because the consultants have identified five critical priorities.
1. Improve product quality.
2. Look after existing customers.
3. Reduce unnecessary costs.
4. Support and retain capable employees.
5. Focus on profitable sales.
Dave stares at the screen.
Then looks at Quentin.
Then looks back at the screen.
"Isn't that what we were doing before you arrived?"
Quentin smiles.
"Exactly, Dave. We're recommending a return to a more focused, customer-centric operating model."
Fucking magnificent.
The company has spent hundreds of thousands of pounds discovering that it should return to doing the things that made it successful in the first place.
The board approves the recommendations.
A new transformation programme is launched.
PROJECT BACK TO BASICS.
There's a logo.
Obviously.
The Final Word
And this is what I find so utterly ridiculous about modern corporate life.
We've taken something that is fundamentally understandable and surrounded it with an almost impenetrable layer of self-important bollocks.
We've invented titles for people who don't appear to do anything.
We've created frameworks to explain common sense.
We've turned ordinary behaviour into corporate values.
We've transformed basic communication into stakeholder engagement.
We've made meetings an industry.
We've turned employee satisfaction into an annual administrative exercise.
And we've developed an entire vocabulary designed to make perfectly ordinary activities sound strategically significant.
Of course, large organisations need structure.
They need governance.
They need controls.
They need capable managers.
They need proper planning.
And they sometimes genuinely need to transform the way they operate.
Nobody sensible disputes that.
But there's an enormous difference between necessary complexity and unnecessary corporate theatre.
One helps the business function.
The other helps people feel important.
And perhaps that's the real problem.
Somewhere along the line, corporate Britain became so obsessed with appearing sophisticated that it forgot the value of being straightforward.
A good business doesn't need to pretend it's saving humanity.
It doesn't need six inspirational values to explain that people should behave decently.
It doesn't need a transformation programme every time somebody wants to improve a process.
And it certainly doesn't need Quentin flying business class to Singapore to discover that customers appreciate receiving what they've paid for.
It needs to sell something useful.
Make a reasonable profit.
Look after its customers.
Employ capable people.
Pay them fairly.
Treat them properly.
Make sensible decisions.
And avoid behaving like a collection of self-important fucking idiots.
That's it.
That's the revolutionary strategy.
No pillars.
No roadmap.
No steering committee.
No fucking stakeholder alignment workshop.
Just a business.
Doing business.
Although I suppose we could call it a Strategic Commercial Excellence and Sustainable Value Creation Framework.
Charge £250,000 for the implementation.
And send Quentin to Dubai to announce it.