The Innovation Workshop: Let's Put Some Post-it Notes on a Fucking Wall
There are few things in corporate life more depressing than receiving a meeting invitation containing the words Innovation Workshop.
Not because innovation is a bad thing.
Innovation is wonderful.
Innovation gave us electricity, antibiotics, the internet and the ability to order a kebab without having to speak to another human being.
All genuinely impressive achievements.
But corporate innovation is slightly different.
Corporate innovation usually involves twelve middle managers, a packet of coloured Post-it notes and a man called Quentin explaining how important it is to think outside the box.
In a room.
Inside an office.
Where absolutely everything is governed by a fucking box.
The workshop invitation arrives on a Tuesday.
INNOVATION WORKSHOP: REIMAGINING THE ART OF THE POSSIBLE.
Oh, for fuck's sake.
What does that even mean?
The art of the possible?
We're a business, Quentin.
We're not exploring the philosophical boundaries of human existence.
We're trying to work out why it takes six weeks to approve a fucking laptop.
The Exciting Opportunity
The email explains that the organisation is embarking on an exciting journey to unlock innovative thinking and challenge established ways of working.
Apparently, leadership wants to hear from employees.
All ideas are welcome.
Nothing is off-limits.
There are no stupid suggestions.
This is a safe space for creativity.
Which sounds lovely.
Except I attended a meeting last Thursday where somebody suggested removing an unnecessary approval stage and was immediately told that doing so would breach the governance framework.
But apparently, Thursday was not an innovation day.
Today is different.
Today, we're allowed to think freely.
Between 9:30 am and 12:30 pm.
Subject to availability.
And approval from our line managers.
The Facilitator
We arrive at the conference room.
There's a flipchart.
A projector.
Six packets of Post-it notes.
Several enormous sheets of paper.
And a table covered in felt-tip pens.
It's like walking into a primary school classroom, except the children are middle-aged, considerably more expensive and somehow less capable of making independent decisions.
At the front stands our facilitator.
His name is Julian.
Julian is wearing a bright blue shirt, fashionable trainers and the expression of a man who's just discovered the meaning of life in a TED Talk.
He's one of those corporate facilitators who smiles constantly.
Not a normal smile.
An aggressive smile.
The sort of smile that makes you wonder whether his facial muscles have been permanently secured in place with industrial adhesive.
"GOOD MORNING, EVERYONE!"
Jesus Christ.
It's 9:30.
We're indoors.
You don't need to announce yourself like a fucking children's television presenter.
Julian explains that today is about collaboration, creativity and challenging our assumptions.
"We want to create an environment where everyone feels empowered to contribute."
Wonderful.
Can I contribute by going back to work?
Apparently not.
The Icebreaker
Naturally, before we can innovate, we must complete an icebreaker.
Because nothing encourages sophisticated professional thinking quite like forcing adults to participate in activities designed for seven-year-olds.
Julian asks everyone to introduce themselves and describe what animal best represents their working style.
What?
What the actual fuck?
I'm a professional adult.
I have a mortgage.
I pay council tax.
I've been working for decades.
And now I'm being asked whether I'm a fucking meerkat.
Sandra from HR goes first.
"I'm a dolphin because I'm collaborative, intelligent and love working with others."
Of course you are, Sandra.
Kevin from Operations chooses a lion.
"I'm a natural leader. I like to take charge and drive results."
Kevin, you're an assistant operations manager.
You once spent forty minutes trying to work out how to attach a PDF to an email.
You're not a lion.
You're a confused Labrador wearing a lanyard.
Martin, the senior manager, chooses an eagle.
Apparently, he likes to see the bigger picture.
Which is interesting because Martin has demonstrated a remarkable inability to see anything happening directly in front of him.
He can see the bigger picture.
He just can't see the fourteen unanswered emails sitting in his inbox.
Eventually, it's my turn.
"What animal would you be?"
"A sloth."
Julian laughs.
"And why's that?"
"Because I'd rather be asleep than sitting here."
Apparently, that's not quite the spirit we're looking for.
Thinking Outside the Box
After forty-five minutes of identifying ourselves as various members of the animal kingdom, we're finally ready to innovate.
Julian draws a large square on the flipchart.
"This represents the box."
Brilliant.
We're already making progress.
He explains that conventional thinking keeps us trapped inside established boundaries.
To innovate, we must challenge those boundaries.
We must be bold.
We must be fearless.
We must think differently.
I raise my hand.
"Could we remove the six-stage approval process for routine purchases?"
Julian beams.
"Fantastic! That's exactly the sort of thinking we're looking for!"
Excellent.
"However, we'd obviously need to ensure any changes remain aligned with our existing procurement governance framework."
Right.
So we can't remove it?
"Well, we'd need to explore that."
Could we simplify it?
"Potentially, subject to stakeholder consultation."
Could we at least reduce the number of people who need to approve things?
"That would require a formal process review."
And there it is.
Think outside the box, provided you remain inside the box at all times.
The box is sacred.
The box has policies.
The box has procedures.
The box has a governance committee.
And if you want to leave the box, you'll need to complete Form BX-17 and obtain written approval from the Head of Boxes.
The Post-it Notes
Now comes the main event.
The Post-it notes.
Julian distributes several packets and asks us to write down our ideas.
One idea per note.
No criticism.
No judgement.
No limitations.
We're encouraged to be ambitious.
Apparently, we're going to generate as many ideas as possible.
Quantity over quality.
Which is a fascinating approach for an organisation that claims to value excellence.
Kevin immediately starts writing.
He's absolutely fucking delighted.
Kevin loves workshops.
Workshops are Kevin's natural habitat.
Give him a flipchart and a packet of coloured pens and he'll happily spend six hours producing absolutely nothing of commercial value.
He's the human equivalent of a screensaver.
Constantly moving.
Occasionally colourful.
Fundamentally pointless.
Sandra writes IMPROVE COMMUNICATION.
Martin writes ENHANCE COLLABORATION.
Someone else writes DRIVE EFFICIENCY.
Kevin writes LEVERAGE DIGITAL OPPORTUNITIES.
What does that mean, Kevin?
"Well, I think we need to leverage digital opportunities."
Yes, but which opportunities?
"Digital ones."
Fucking magnificent.
I write:
STOP HAVING POINTLESS MEETINGS.
Julian looks delighted.
"Great energy!"
Then I write:
REMOVE UNNECESSARY APPROVALS.
Then:
STOP CREATING NEW PROCESSES TO FIX EXISTING PROCESSES.
Then:
LET PEOPLE WHO UNDERSTAND THE WORK MAKE DECISIONS.
Julian's smile begins to deteriorate.
The Wall of Innovation
After thirty minutes, we're instructed to stick our ideas on the wall.
There's a tremendous amount of activity.
People are standing.
Moving around.
Discussing things.
Pointing at notes.
Nodding thoughtfully.
From a distance, it looks incredibly productive.
Like a colony of ants constructing something important.
Except ants generally manage to achieve something without appointing a Head of Ant Transformation.
Julian steps back and surveys the wall.
"Wow. Just look at all that creativity!"
There are approximately 140 Post-it notes.
Seventy of them say essentially the same thing.
Improve communication.
Enhance collaboration.
Simplify processes.
Increase efficiency.
Encourage innovation.
Empower employees.
The rest are either incomprehensible or written by Kevin.
Julian is ecstatic.
"This is fantastic. We've generated a huge number of really valuable ideas."
Have we?
Because from where I'm standing, we've spent an hour writing down things that everybody already knows.
The company needs better communication.
Really?
Fucking extraordinary.
We need simpler processes?
Stop the presses.
Employees should be empowered to make decisions?
What a remarkable discovery.
Somebody should inform the Chief Executive immediately.
The Grouping Exercise
Unfortunately, we're not finished.
Now we have to group the Post-it notes into themes.
Julian explains that this will help identify common opportunities.
So we spend another forty-five minutes moving little pieces of paper around.
Communication goes with collaboration.
Efficiency goes with process improvement.
Innovation goes with digital transformation.
Kevin suggests that customer experience should be grouped with operational excellence.
Sandra disagrees.
Martin thinks we should create a separate category for strategic enablement.
Nobody knows what strategic enablement means.
But everyone agrees it sounds important.
Eventually, the wall contains five categories.
People.
Process.
Technology.
Customers.
Culture.
Wonderful.
We've successfully identified the five things that almost every organisation on the planet has been discussing since approximately 1987.
Julian takes a photograph.
Naturally.
The photograph is very important.
Because the photograph proves the workshop happened.
And in corporate Britain, proof that something happened is often considerably more valuable than evidence that anything was achieved.
The Best Practice Problem
Now we begin discussing which ideas could actually be implemented.
This is where the fun starts.
One employee suggests simplifying the customer onboarding process.
Excellent idea.
Unfortunately, the existing process is based on industry best practice.
Ah.
Best practice.
Those two magical words that can bring almost any sensible discussion to a grinding halt.
Apparently, best practice is something that must never be questioned.
Because somebody, somewhere, once decided it was the correct way to do something.
Who?
Nobody knows.
When?
Unclear.
Why?
Because it's best practice.
And that's apparently sufficient.
It's the corporate equivalent of your grandmother telling you to do something because that's how it's always been done.
Except your grandmother didn't charge £200 an hour for process consultancy.
Another employee suggests reducing the amount of documentation required for routine changes.
"Unfortunately, our current approach aligns with recognised best practice."
Right.
But it's taking three days to complete something that should take twenty minutes.
"Yes, but we need to ensure compliance."
Could we change the process?
"We'd need to assess the implications."
Could we review whether all the documentation is necessary?
"That would require governance approval."
Of course it fucking would.
We've created a system in which the process for improving a process is more complicated than the process we're trying to improve.
And apparently, this is operational excellence.
The Red Tape
Next, we discuss decision-making.
Someone suggests allowing experienced employees to approve low-risk activities without escalating everything to management.
A perfectly reasonable idea.
It could save time.
Reduce delays.
Improve accountability.
And free managers to concentrate on more important matters.
Unfortunately, there are concerns.
Risk management.
Audit requirements.
Compliance.
Segregation of duties.
Governance.
Controls.
Now, to be clear, these things can be genuinely important.
Nobody sensible wants employees transferring company money into their personal bank accounts because they've been empowered to think outside the box.
But there's a difference between sensible controls and bureaucratic constipation.
And some organisations appear to have developed an extraordinary ability to confuse the two.
You want to replace a broken mouse?
Approval required.
You want to update a routine document?
Approval required.
You want to make a minor improvement to an established process?
Impact assessment.
Risk review.
Stakeholder consultation.
Change advisory board.
Implementation plan.
Backout plan.
Post-implementation review.
And possibly a fucking papal blessing.
But today is about innovation.
So Julian encourages us to remain positive.
"Let's not focus on the barriers."
The barriers, Julian, are the entire fucking problem.
That's why we're here.
The Managerial Jolly
By lunchtime, something becomes increasingly obvious.
The managers are having a wonderful time.
They're smiling.
They're networking.
They're discussing opportunities.
They're exchanging ideas.
They're taking photographs.
And they're congratulating one another on the quality of the engagement.
Martin is particularly pleased.
He has already informed his manager that the workshop has been a tremendous success.
"Really productive morning. Fantastic collaboration across the business."
How does he know?
We haven't implemented anything.
We haven't agreed any changes.
We haven't solved a single problem.
But apparently, that doesn't matter.
The workshop has demonstrated leadership.
It has shown initiative.
It has encouraged engagement.
And most importantly, Martin can now include it in his annual performance review.
Led a cross-functional innovation initiative to identify strategic improvement opportunities across the organisation.
What an achievement.
Three hours in a meeting room moving Post-it notes around.
A photograph of a wall.
And a sentence that makes Martin sound like he's personally invented the fucking internet.
Meanwhile, the employees who actually understand the problems have lost half a working day.
Their deadlines haven't moved.
Their workloads haven't reduced.
And they'll probably have to work late to catch up.
But Martin has demonstrated strategic leadership.
So that's nice.
The Action Plan
After lunch, Julian announces that we need to turn our ideas into actions.
Finally.
Something useful.
Perhaps we're actually going to make a decision.
Unfortunately, this is corporate Britain.
So instead, we create an action plan.
Every idea must have an owner.
A priority.
A target date.
A status.
A risk rating.
And a description of the expected benefits.
Julian opens a spreadsheet.
There are fourteen columns.
Fourteen.
For ideas written on pieces of fucking paper.
We begin assigning owners.
The managers are delighted to sponsor the initiatives.
Sponsorship, apparently, means supporting something without necessarily having to do it.
The actual work is allocated to employees.
Naturally.
Sarah is asked to review the onboarding process.
David is asked to assess approval workflows.
Raj is asked to investigate opportunities for automation.
Kevin volunteers to coordinate the innovation communications workstream.
Of course he does.
Kevin has found his calling.
He'll be sending fortnightly newsletters about the progress of initiatives that haven't progressed.
Martin agrees to provide executive oversight.
Which means he'll occasionally ask why things haven't been completed.
And Julian?
Julian has another workshop next week.
Different company.
Same Post-it notes.
The Governance Committee
Two weeks later, the first proposed improvement reaches the governance committee.
It's a simple idea.
Remove an unnecessary approval stage from a low-risk internal process.
The change would save time.
Reduce administration.
And allow employees to complete routine work more efficiently.
Everyone agrees it's sensible.
Unfortunately, the committee has concerns.
The proposed change hasn't been reviewed by the process owner.
The process owner is on annual leave.
The risk assessment needs updating.
The compliance team hasn't provided formal approval.
And the supporting documentation doesn't use the latest template.
So the proposal is deferred.
Until next month.
The following month, the committee meets again.
Unfortunately, there's a new concern.
The organisation is currently reviewing its operating model.
It would be inappropriate to make changes before the review is complete.
So the proposal is deferred again.
Three months later, the operating model review is completed.
Unfortunately, it recommends establishing a new process improvement framework.
Which means the original proposal must now be resubmitted under the new framework.
At this point, David quietly gives up.
And who can fucking blame him?
The Innovation Newsletter
Six months later, an email arrives.
INNOVATION UPDATE: CELEBRATING OUR PROGRESS.
Oh, here we go.
Apparently, the workshop was an outstanding success.
The company generated 140 ideas.
Identified five strategic themes.
Established twelve improvement workstreams.
Created an innovation governance framework.
And launched a dedicated communications channel.
Wonderful.
How many improvements have actually been implemented?
Three.
One involves changing the wording on an internal form.
Another introduces a new Teams channel.
And the third is a revised meeting structure.
A revised meeting structure.
We attended a workshop to reduce unnecessary bureaucracy and somehow created another fucking meeting.
But the newsletter is full of inspirational language.
Momentum.
Progress.
Collaboration.
Transformation.
Continuous improvement.
There's even a photograph of the Post-it wall.
Again.
Martin has been nominated for an internal leadership award.
For championing innovation.
The award citation praises his commitment to empowering employees and driving meaningful change.
The employees who suggested the improvements are still waiting for their ideas to be approved.
The Next Workshop
Eventually, senior leadership decides that the organisation needs to accelerate innovation.
Apparently, progress has been slower than expected.
Nobody can understand why.
Perhaps employees aren't sufficiently engaged.
Perhaps the culture needs strengthening.
Perhaps people need to become more comfortable challenging established ways of working.
So management announces another workshop.
This time, the focus will be on removing barriers to innovation.
Fantastic.
Perhaps we'll finally discuss the bureaucracy, unnecessary approvals and management indecision that prevented anything happening after the first workshop.
Unfortunately, the invitation explains that the session will focus on developing an innovation mindset.
There will be an external facilitator.
Group exercises.
Breakout discussions.
And an opportunity to share ideas.
Attendees are encouraged to bring an open mind.
And a willingness to challenge conventional thinking.
I reply with a suggestion.
"Could we just implement some of the ideas from the last workshop?"
Martin responds.
"Let's not jump ahead. We need to make sure we follow the process."
Fucking hell.
The Final Word
And this is what makes corporate innovation workshops so spectacularly ridiculous.
The problem usually isn't a shortage of ideas.
Employees have ideas all the time.
They know which processes are unnecessarily complicated.
They know which systems don't work.
They know where time is being wasted.
They know which decisions take too long.
And they often know exactly how to improve things.
Because they're the people actually doing the fucking work.
What they frequently lack isn't creativity.
It's authority.
It's time.
It's resources.
It's management support.
And it's an organisation willing to change the very processes it claims to want improved.
But instead of addressing those problems, companies organise workshops.
They hire facilitators.
They buy Post-it notes.
They create action plans.
They establish governance committees.
And they congratulate themselves on their commitment to innovation.
Because workshops are visible.
They're measurable.
They produce photographs.
They generate reports.
And they give managers something impressive to discuss with their own managers.
Actual innovation is much less convenient.
It requires decisions.
It requires responsibility.
It sometimes requires challenging established practices.
And occasionally, it requires somebody senior to admit that the existing process is a complete fucking waste of time.
Which is considerably harder than putting a yellow square of paper on a wall.
So here's my revolutionary proposal.
Stop holding innovation workshops and start listening to the people who already know what's wrong.
Give them the authority to improve things.
Remove unnecessary bureaucracy.
Challenge processes that no longer serve a useful purpose.
And judge success by what actually changes.
Not how many ideas were generated.
Not how many workshops were held.
Not how many action logs were created.
And certainly not how many photographs Martin uploaded to LinkedIn.
Because if you spend three hours encouraging employees to think outside the box, then another six months explaining why none of their ideas can be implemented...
You haven't created a culture of innovation.
You've created a fucking arts and crafts club for middle management.