The Promotion Process: Congratulations, You're Now Responsible for Promoting Yourself
There was a time when managers were responsible for managing people.
I appreciate that sounds ridiculous.
But apparently, many years ago, managers would observe their employees, understand their capabilities, recognise their achievements and help them progress through the organisation.
An extraordinary concept.
Unfortunately, modern corporate Britain has decided that this arrangement places an unreasonable burden on management.
After all, managers are very busy.
They have meetings.
Important meetings.
Meetings about other meetings.
And occasionally a meeting to discuss why nobody has completed the actions from the previous meeting.
So, in a bold move towards employee empowerment, the organisation has announced a revolutionary new approach to career progression.
You are now responsible for your own promotion.
Wonderful.
Management has successfully outsourced management.
To the people they're supposed to be managing.
Taking Ownership of Your Career
The announcement arrives in an email from HR.
It's titled:
EMPOWERING OUR PEOPLE TO OWN THEIR CAREER JOURNEY.
Already, I want to throw my laptop through a window.
The email explains that the company is moving towards a more employee-led approach to professional development.
Apparently, this will encourage ownership, accountability, ambition and proactive career conversations.
What it actually means is that your manager can now spend even less time managing you.
Previously, you might reasonably have expected your manager to notice that you'd been doing the job above your pay grade for the last eighteen months.
Now you have to notice it yourself.
Then document it.
Then demonstrate it.
Then provide evidence.
Then map that evidence against a competency framework apparently written by someone who has never performed an identifiable piece of work in their entire fucking life.
And finally, you must arrange a meeting with your manager to explain why you're worth promoting.
Your manager, meanwhile, will be delighted to support you.
In principle.
The Competency Framework
Before you can apply for promotion, you must demonstrate that you are already operating at the next level.
Not that you have the potential to operate at the next level.
Not that you've developed the skills required.
You must already be doing the fucking job.
For free.
Ideally for at least a year.
This is considered a fair and transparent process.
Imagine applying this logic anywhere else.
You walk into a restaurant and explain that you'd like to become a chef.
"Excellent," says the head chef. "You'll need to prepare all the meals, manage the kitchen and supervise the staff for twelve months before we consider paying you as a chef."
"Right. And what will I be paid in the meantime?"
"Kitchen porter."
Corporate career progression.
Where the reward for demonstrating that you're capable of doing a more senior job is the opportunity to continue doing it without the corresponding salary.
But don't worry.
There's a framework.
And the framework is very important.
It contains phrases such as:
Demonstrates strategic thinking.
Influences stakeholders across complex organisational boundaries.
Drives measurable business outcomes.
Exhibits leadership behaviours aligned with corporate values.
Nobody knows what any of this means.
Including the people assessing it.
But you'd better demonstrate it.
Preferably in a spreadsheet.
The Evidence
You now begin the process of documenting everything you've achieved.
Projects delivered.
Problems solved.
Teams supported.
Clients managed.
Deadlines met.
Difficult situations resolved.
You produce a comprehensive record of your contribution to the organisation.
Thirty pages.
Supporting examples.
Quantifiable outcomes.
Feedback from colleagues.
Testimonials from clients.
You have essentially prepared a legal defence against the accusation that you deserve more money.
Eventually, you send it to your manager.
"Hi, Martin. I've put together my promotion evidence. Would you mind reviewing it and giving me some feedback?"
Martin replies three days later.
"Looks good, mate. Happy to support."
Brilliant.
What does he think of the evidence?
Does it demonstrate the required competencies?
Are there any gaps?
What should you strengthen?
Does he believe you're operating at the next level?
Nobody knows.
Because Martin hasn't read it.
But he's happy to support.
And in corporate Britain, apparently, that's enough.
The Invisible Manager
Now, to be fair, Martin is a very approachable manager.
He tells everyone this regularly.
"My door is always open."
A lovely sentiment.
Unfortunately, nobody knows where the fucking door is.
Martin is permanently unavailable.
His Teams status is either Busy, In a Meeting or Away.
His calendar resembles the departure board at Heathrow during a national air traffic control failure.
You need fifteen minutes to discuss your career.
Martin has availability in six weeks.
At 4:30 pm.
On a Friday.
But Martin genuinely cares about his people.
He even tells them that he doesn't believe in unnecessary bureaucracy.
For example, if you're feeling a bit tired and fancy taking a day off, Martin has a wonderfully flexible approach.
"Look, mate, if you need a day, just take one. Don't worry about putting it through the HR system. I don't want the paperwork that this will cause!"
What a progressive leader.
What an enlightened approach to employee wellbeing.
What a complete fucking shambles.
Of course, Martin is keen to establish that this flexibility mustn't be abused.
"Just don't take the piss, yeah? I can spot patterns."
Oh, can you, Martin?
You can spot patterns?
What, like somebody taking every Friday off for six consecutive months?
Fucking Sherlock Holmes has entered the building.
"Interesting. That's the twenty-sixth consecutive Friday Kevin has been unavailable. I'm beginning to suspect some sort of recurring arrangement."
Extraordinary detective work.
Perhaps Martin could apply those remarkable observational abilities to something else.
Like noticing which employees are consistently delivering work above their grade.
Or identifying people who are ready for promotion.
Or recognising that his entire team has been doing three people's jobs since the last restructure.
But no.
Martin's extraordinary powers of pattern recognition are reserved for detecting suspiciously regular absences.
The rest of the time, he's unavailable.
The Career Conversation
Eventually, after several weeks of chasing, you secure a meeting with Martin.
You've prepared your evidence.
You've identified your achievements.
You've mapped everything against the competency framework.
You've even written a short opening statement explaining why you believe you're ready for promotion.
Martin joins the call four minutes late.
"Sorry, mate. Been absolutely manic."
Of course you have.
"Right, so what did you want to discuss?"
My promotion, Martin.
The promotion I've been emailing you about for two months.
The promotion evidence I sent you.
The promotion meeting you accepted.
That fucking promotion.
"Oh yeah, absolutely. So where do you see yourself going?"
Well, ideally, Martin, into the job I've already been doing for the last eighteen months.
"Great. Love the ambition."
He nods thoughtfully.
"Have you thought about taking ownership of your development?"
Have I thought about it?
I've written thirty fucking pages about it.
I've identified the competencies, gathered the evidence, spoken to stakeholders, documented the outcomes and arranged this meeting.
What precisely would you like me to own next?
The company?
"Yeah, brilliant. Just keep doing what you're doing."
And there it is.
The most useless sentence in corporate management.
Just keep doing what you're doing.
The professional equivalent of telling someone who's lost in the woods to continue walking.
The Promotion Panel
Eventually, your application reaches the promotion panel.
A mysterious gathering of senior managers who have never worked with you, never observed your performance and possibly couldn't identify you in a police lineup.
They will now decide whether you deserve a promotion.
Based on your evidence.
And your manager's recommendation.
The manager who hasn't read your evidence.
The panel considers your application carefully.
Apparently, you've demonstrated strong delivery, leadership, stakeholder management and commercial awareness.
Excellent.
However, there is one concern.
You need to demonstrate more strategic visibility.
Strategic visibility.
What the fuck is strategic visibility?
Do I need to wear a fluorescent jacket during management meetings?
Should I stand outside the CEO's office holding a sign?
HELLO. I AM BEING STRATEGIC. PLEASE PROMOTE ME.
Perhaps I should start every Teams meeting by announcing that I'm operating at the next level.
"Morning, everyone. Before we begin, I'd just like to confirm that my contributions today will be strategically aligned with the expectations of a senior leadership role."
But apparently, visibility matters.
Not simply doing the work.
Not delivering results.
Not solving problems.
Being seen doing them.
Preferably by someone important.
And if the panel doesn't know who you are, well, perhaps you should have spent less time working and more time networking with people who don't know what you do.
The Feedback
Eventually, the decision arrives.
Unfortunately, you haven't been successful on this occasion.
Disappointing.
But the company wants to reassure you that your contribution is highly valued.
Naturally.
They encourage you to continue developing your leadership capabilities and building your professional profile.
You ask for specific feedback.
What was missing?
Which competency wasn't demonstrated?
What would you need to do differently?
Martin promises to find out.
"Leave it with me, mate."
Three weeks later, you ask again.
"Any update, Martin?"
"Still chasing, mate."
Of course you are.
Another fortnight passes.
Eventually, Martin returns with the official feedback.
"Just keep doing what you're doing."
Fucking magnificent.
The Beauty of Employee-Led Progression
And this is what makes the modern corporate promotion process such a masterpiece.
The employee is responsible for identifying their potential.
The employee is responsible for documenting their achievements.
The employee is responsible for gathering evidence.
The employee is responsible for arranging career conversations.
The employee is responsible for demonstrating readiness.
The employee is responsible for chasing feedback.
And management?
Management is responsible for supporting the process.
In principle.
When available.
Subject to diary commitments.
And, of course, business priorities.
It's a remarkable arrangement.
The company gets employees performing at higher levels without necessarily paying them higher salaries.
Managers get to describe themselves as supportive without having to do very much supporting.
And HR gets to produce a colourful infographic explaining how everyone is empowered to take ownership of their career journey.
Everybody wins.
Except the employee.
Who is still doing the same job.
For the same money.
With thirty pages of evidence demonstrating why they shouldn't be.
Welcome to modern corporate career progression.
Where your manager is no longer responsible for managing your career, but somehow remains responsible for deciding whether you're allowed to have one.