A Better Way

The Town Hall: An Hour of Corporate Bollocks That Could Have Been an Email

The first time I received an invitation to a corporate Town Hall, I was genuinely quite excited.

Not because I particularly wanted to attend.

But because I thought we were going to an actual town hall.

You know.

A large civic building.

Possibly Victorian.

High ceilings. Wooden benches. A clock tower.

Perhaps the Mayor would be there.

I imagined hundreds of people gathering in an impressive municipal building to discuss something of genuine importance.

Then I discovered that the Town Hall was actually taking place in Meeting Room 4B.

On the second floor.

Next to the fucking toilets.

And approximately fifty people were expected to squeeze into a room designed to accommodate eighteen.

Welcome to corporate Britain.

Where even the name of a meeting has to sound more important than the meeting itself.

Why Is It Called a Town Hall?

Seriously.

Why?

It's a company update.

That's what it is.

A company.

Providing an update.

To its employees.

Company Update Meeting.

There you go.

Four words.

Everybody understands them.

But apparently, that's not sufficiently inspirational.

No.

We need a Town Hall.

Because Town Hall sounds inclusive.

Collaborative.

Democratic.

It suggests openness, transparency and a genuine opportunity for employees to engage with senior leadership.

Which is interesting.

Because the last thing most senior leadership teams want is fifty employees asking them difficult questions.

But we'll get to that.

First, we need to find somewhere to sit.

The Venue

Meeting Room 4B is full.

Naturally.

There are forty-eight chairs.

Fifty-seven employees.

Three senior executives.

A projector.

A table containing six bottles of water.

And a man from IT trying to work out why the presentation won't display.

It's 9:02 am.

The meeting was supposed to start at nine.

Someone has suggested standing at the back.

Someone else is sitting on a windowsill.

A senior manager is attempting to operate the air conditioning.

It's November.

The room is approximately thirty degrees.

And there's a faint smell of carpet tiles, cheap coffee and human despair.

Eventually, the Managing Director arrives.

He's wearing a company-branded polo shirt.

Because today is about accessibility.

He's one of us.

Just an ordinary bloke.

An ordinary bloke who earns approximately six times what the rest of us do and has his own parking space.

"Morning, everyone!"

Silence.

"Come on, we can do better than that!"

Can we?

Can we really?

It's nine o'clock on a Tuesday.

I'm standing behind a filing cabinet because there aren't enough chairs.

And I've just discovered that this meeting is scheduled for ninety fucking minutes.

What exactly would you like me to do?

Start a Mexican wave?

The Exciting Business Update

The Managing Director begins.

"First of all, I just want to say what an incredible quarter we've had."

Of course.

It's always an incredible quarter.

I've never attended a Town Hall where the opening announcement was:

"Morning, everyone. We've had an absolutely fucking disastrous three months."

No.

Every quarter is incredible.

Every year is challenging but exciting.

Every financial result demonstrates resilience.

Every missed target represents an opportunity.

And every organisational failure is apparently part of a wider transformation journey.

The Managing Director clicks to the next slide.

There's a graph.

Naturally.

The graph contains twelve coloured lines, three percentages and an arrow pointing upwards.

"Despite some challenging market conditions, we've delivered strong underlying performance."

What does that mean?

Have we made money?

"Well, revenue is slightly below expectations."

Right.

So no.

"But we've made significant progress against our strategic priorities."

Which are?

"Growth, innovation, operational excellence and customer-centric transformation."

Jesus fucking Christ.

It's not even half past nine.

The Strategic Announcement

Next comes the big announcement.

The company has developed a new strategy.

Again.

Apparently, the previous strategy, announced nine months ago, is no longer sufficiently strategic.

So the leadership team has spent several weeks developing a refreshed strategic direction.

There's a new diagram.

Three circles.

Four pillars.

Five priorities.

And a slogan.

BUILDING TOMORROW, TOGETHER.

Wonderful.

What does it mean?

Nobody knows.

But the circles overlap beautifully.

The Managing Director explains that the organisation will be focusing on sustainable growth, operational efficiency, customer relationships and innovation.

Extraordinary.

A business wants to grow, operate efficiently, keep its customers and develop new products.

Someone alert the Financial Times.

This is revolutionary.

I'm particularly impressed by the commitment to operational efficiency.

Because we've just taken fifty-seven employees away from their actual jobs to listen to a man explain that the company needs to become more efficient.

Perhaps we could start by cancelling this fucking meeting.

Saving the Planet

Now comes the environmental update.

The company is committed to sustainability.

Very committed.

Incredibly committed.

Possibly the most committed organisation in the history of environmental commitment.

There's a photograph of a tree.

A wind turbine.

And three smiling employees wearing fluorescent jackets.

Apparently, the company has reduced its carbon footprint.

Wonderful.

It's introduced new recycling initiatives.

Fantastic.

It's committed to reducing unnecessary travel.

Excellent.

Which is interesting.

Because last month, seventeen senior managers flew to Barcelona for a leadership conference.

But that was different.

That was a strategic event.

The conference focused on sustainability.

Naturally.

And collaboration.

And leadership alignment.

And possibly tapas.

Meanwhile, employees are being encouraged to print less.

Because every little helps.

The Managing Director proudly announces that the organisation has saved enough paper to fill three Olympic swimming pools.

I'm not entirely sure that's how paper works.

But everyone applauds.

Apparently, we've saved the planet.

Well done, everybody.

The Charity Update

Next comes the charity update.

The company has raised £8,400 for a very worthy cause.

Which is genuinely a good thing.

I'm not disputing that.

Charities need support.

People doing something to help others deserve recognition.

But apparently, the company cannot simply donate money without turning it into a corporate publicity campaign.

There's a photograph.

Of course there's a photograph.

Twelve senior managers standing behind an enormous novelty cheque.

All smiling.

All wearing company-branded clothing.

One of them is holding a balloon.

The Managing Director explains that giving back to the community is central to the organisation's values.

Wonderful.

But why am I being shown seventeen photographs of executives standing next to a cheque?

Just give them the fucking money.

You don't need a Town Hall.

You don't need a PowerPoint presentation.

You don't need Quentin from Business Development explaining how profoundly moved he was by the experience.

And you certainly don't need a LinkedIn post describing the donation as an inspiring demonstration of our collective commitment to meaningful social impact.

It's charity.

Not the fucking Oscars.

Quentin's Excellent Adventure

Speaking of Quentin.

Apparently, Quentin has recently returned from Singapore.

On business.

Important business.

Strategic business.

Business so important that it required five nights in a luxury hotel and several photographs of Quentin standing beside interesting architecture.

We're now being treated to a presentation about the trip.

Quentin takes the microphone.

"Thanks, everyone. Really exciting opportunity to engage with some key stakeholders in the region."

Wonderful.

What did you achieve?

"Well, we had some incredibly productive conversations."

About what?

"Exploring opportunities for future collaboration."

Right.

Did we win any business?

"Not directly, but we've established some really valuable relationships."

Of course you have.

And apparently, these relationships required business-class flights, a five-star hotel and an evening networking event involving cocktails beside a rooftop swimming pool.

But it's all for the good of the company.

Strategic relationship building.

Very important.

Meanwhile, somebody in IT has been waiting six weeks for approval to purchase a replacement monitor.

Unfortunately, there's no budget.

But Quentin's trip has been an outstanding success.

There's even a photograph of him shaking hands with another man in a suit.

The slide is titled:

EXPANDING OUR GLOBAL FOOTPRINT.

What footprint?

You've been on a fucking aeroplane, Quentin.

Celebrating Our People

Now comes the employee recognition section.

Apparently, our people are our greatest asset.

They always are.

I've never worked for a company that announced:

"Actually, our greatest asset is the building. The employees are a fucking nuisance."

No.

People are everything.

People are at the heart of the business.

People drive our success.

People make the difference.

Which is lovely.

Until those people ask for a pay rise.

Then they're an operational cost.

But today is about celebration.

Several employees have been nominated for going above and beyond.

One has worked late to deliver an important project.

Another has supported a colleague during a difficult period.

And Sandra from HR has organised a successful charity bake sale.

The winners receive a certificate.

And a round of applause.

Possibly a £10 voucher.

The Managing Director explains that these individuals embody the company's values.

Wonderful.

Perhaps we could embody those values by paying them properly.

But apparently, that's not how recognition works.

Recognition is about appreciation.

Not money.

Money would be vulgar.

The Employee Engagement Results

Next comes the employee engagement survey.

This is always entertaining.

Apparently, the organisation recently asked employees how they feel about working there.

An excellent initiative.

Although I suspect management might regret asking.

The Managing Director explains that overall engagement remains strong.

Interesting.

Because several departments appear to have lost half their staff.

But the results are positive.

Mostly.

There are, however, a few areas for improvement.

Employees have expressed concerns about workload.

Career progression.

Communication.

Leadership visibility.

And remuneration.

So, essentially, everything.

But management has listened.

They've taken the feedback seriously.

Very seriously.

And they're delighted to announce a comprehensive action plan.

There will be workshops.

Focus groups.

Listening sessions.

And a new employee engagement working group.

Fantastic.

What about the pay?

"That's something we'll continue to review."

Career progression?

"We're developing a framework."

Workload?

"We encourage everyone to prioritise their wellbeing."

Leadership visibility?

"Well, that's exactly why we're holding these Town Halls."

Oh, fuck off.

Questions and Answers

Finally, we reach the most exciting part of the Town Hall.

The Q&A.

Apparently, this is our opportunity to ask senior leadership anything.

Anything at all.

No question is off-limits.

The Managing Director smiles.

"We really want to encourage open and honest dialogue."

Excellent.

An employee raises their hand.

"Given the company's financial performance, will there be any meaningful salary increases this year?"

The Managing Director nods thoughtfully.

"Great question."

It's always a great question.

Nobody has ever asked a bad question at a Town Hall.

"Remuneration is something we take incredibly seriously. We regularly benchmark our packages against the wider market, and we're committed to remaining competitive while balancing the needs of the business."

Right.

So is that a yes or a no?

"Well, it's an ongoing conversation."

Of course it fucking is.

Another employee asks about career progression.

"Another excellent question."

Naturally.

"We're committed to empowering employees to take ownership of their professional development."

Brilliant.

So management isn't responsible for that either.

Someone asks about the number of people leaving the organisation.

"That's a really important point."

Here we go.

"Attrition is something we're monitoring closely, and we're continuing to invest in our employee value proposition."

Employee value proposition.

Jesus Christ.

People are leaving because they're overworked, underpaid and fed up.

But apparently, the solution is to invest in a proposition.

Someone asks why the company is recruiting externally while existing employees are struggling to secure promotions.

The Managing Director smiles.

"That's a complex question, and probably one we should take offline."

There it is.

Take it offline.

The corporate equivalent of putting a difficult question in a drawer and setting fire to the drawer.

The Final Five Minutes

Eventually, the Managing Director announces that we're running out of time.

What a shame.

We were just getting to the interesting questions.

"Unfortunately, we won't be able to cover everything today."

Naturally.

"But please do reach out to your line managers if you have any concerns."

Wonderful.

The same line managers who are permanently unavailable.

"Before we finish, I just want to thank everyone for their incredible contribution."

Here it comes.

"We've achieved so much together, and I'm genuinely excited about what lies ahead."

Of course you are.

"We've got a fantastic team, a clear strategy and some really exciting opportunities."

Excellent.

Can we leave now?

"Let's give ourselves a round of applause."

Oh, for fuck's sake.

And there we are.

Fifty-seven adults applauding themselves for attending a meeting.

The Managing Director thanks everyone again.

The screen displays the company logo.

Underneath it are the words:

ONE TEAM. ONE FUTURE. ONE VISION.

Somebody starts stacking chairs.

The projector is switched off.

And fifty-seven employees return to their desks having learned almost nothing they couldn't have ignored in an email.

The Final Word

And this is what I find so extraordinary about corporate Town Halls.

They're presented as opportunities for transparency, engagement and meaningful communication.

But so often, they're simply elaborate exercises in corporate self-congratulation.

An hour of carefully selected achievements.

Inspirational photographs.

Strategic announcements.

Charity updates.

Environmental commitments.

And senior executives explaining how incredibly exciting everything is.

Meanwhile, employees want to know four things.

Are we doing well?

Are our jobs secure?

Are we getting paid properly?

And is anyone in management going to do something about the problems we've been raising for the last three fucking years?

You could answer those questions in ten minutes.

Or send an email.

An email I'd probably delete.

But at least I wouldn't have to stand behind a filing cabinet while Quentin explains how his business trip to Singapore has transformed the organisation's strategic outlook.

And if the company genuinely wants to improve communication, perhaps it could start by using ordinary language.

Stop calling it a Town Hall.

Stop calling everything a strategic journey.

Stop describing every quarter as incredible.

And stop pretending that fifty people sitting in a meeting room listening to management congratulate itself constitutes employee engagement.

It's a company update.

Call it a fucking company update.

And unless you've got something genuinely important to tell us, send an email.

I'll delete it when I get a minute.

#Corporate Fuckery